Skip to content

"Family Guy": Same as It Ever Was?

Archived

5 replies · 1,031 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Now that Family Guy's back in the air, is it better or worse than before?

Closed
  • Yes, it's better 1 (17%)
  • Maybe, it's similar to before 5 (83%)
  • No, it sucks and should never have come back 0 (0%)
  • No, and it wasn't good to begin with 0 (0%)
  • Wha? 0 (0%)

6 votes · voting closed

I bring this up because Seth McFarlane was able to resurrect the "Family Guy" series thanks to the active viewership of Cartoon Network's "Adult Swim" regulars. Regulars like myself, who learned to love certain aspects of the show that hadn't shown up before when FG was on Fox. Also, the fact that the DVDs from the past seasons were huge sellers certainly didn't hurt.

But there's something...different, this time around. I think I sensed it when watching the return episode on Fox, and that's the fact that nothing ever changes on the show. One of the great things about good sitcoms is how characters develop, but there's none of that on FG. Sure, it's supposed to be a stupid cartoon, but the show that it's often accused of stealing from ("The Simpsons") has been a benchmark of character growth and development (well, except for Homer).

So suddenly the cutaways to pop culture and various other hilarities are still good, but they're the best part of the show. The plots are crap, the characters are static. McFarlane is pushing not only this on America, but also "American Dad", a slightly amusing but mostly groan-inducing half-hour of FG-like animation and lesser-than-FG punchlines. :barf:

Please tell me I'm not the only one who senses something foul in the state of Rhode Island, now that FG is back and worse than ever (it's so bad now, I'm almost beginning to wonder if it was ever good to begin with). Was it better for FG to burn out and fade away, leaving nostalgic memories of a era when it was "good"? Or is the new season better than I think (do the plots actually work for other people? The cutaways are still some of the best in TV, but it's harder to wait for them now).

Anyway, just a long-ass whine on my part, perhaps. I feel betrayed...:nonono:

0 likes

Ditch American Dad. That show is fucking lame. Maybe Seth is afraid of TV Nazis and is keeping it less racier. As long as it is in production the possibility of it improving exists. I watch very mlittle tv but always watch the new FG.

0 likes

Have you seen the 'Stewie movie'?

Far more extreme than the series.

0 likes

I think it's as good as it ever was, maybe even better...lets hope they end it when it's time instead of the long, unholy decay of recent seasons of The Simpsons.

0 likes

Terrence Mason wrote: I think it's as good as it ever was, maybe even better...lets hope they end it when it's time instead of the long, unholy decay of recent seasons of The Simpsons.

YES. One thing that I love about Futurama as well is that it ended far before it began slipping in quality.

0 likes

we don't yet get that here.

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗