The NO Cup Second Round - THE PETER SAVILLE SOUNDTRACK vs AS IT IS WHEN IT WAS

Poll closes 8pm Wednesday 22nd March.

ive never really got into AIIWIW, and like to put on the soundtrack when i can't decide what else to play

AS IT IS WHEN IT WAS it is, one of my favs.

i've never heard TPSS. but, if anyone would like to enlighten me, it would be much appreciated! i guess it would be unfair to vote on 'as it is...' but i still will based on these lyricc: ...the streets are so empty at this time of night / i'd rather walk on my own than fight in a world where i've forgotten you / i found myself forgotten, too... how true!!!

as it is when it was...

this song burns me softly like the sun in autumn...

A no-brainer for me, even though I do like the soundtrack a tad. AIIWIW used to be a monster.

AIIWIW - great lyrics, nice shifts in atmopshere and intensity, my second fave off Brotherhood...

Snorri xxx

As It Is. Always a good live favourite.

As it is

WAS IT WHEN IS IT AS

loved the actual artwork to THE SAVILLE Soundtrack

As it were so to speak:D

Never heard the PSS.

Soundtrack for me. Quality background music and Hooky Bass Porn.

Not really though too hard about whether it beats AIIWIW, which is a real favourite that I'd love to see live. I'm sure mine will only be a token anyway, so why bother

Edit: Soundtrack is doing okay - quite a surprise that!

It is brilliant though

No more f'ing saudade wrote: A no-brainer for me, even though I do like the soundtrack a tad. AIIWIW used to be a monster.

soundtrack just for the variety. so many words in these two choses. lol.

Have never heard The Peter Saville Soundtrack AIIWIW gets my vote by default.