Skip to content

Weekly Song Review: Mr Disco

Archived

37 replies · 5,618 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

This week's review is.. Mr Disco

  1. The best bit
  2. The worst bit
  3. Why you love/hate it
  4. A percentage rating
  5. Which other country would you love to live in?

So here you go, it's up to you! answer any question you want!

0 likes
  1. The best bit: i think it´s a pretty overrated song, so we´re a few that enjoy it! ;)
  2. The worst bit: the name, and the synth bass sounding a little too much like State Of The Nation.
  3. Why you love/hate it: it´s one of those songs you don´t pay much attention but you really enjoy when you remember it and play it.
  4. A percentage rating: 70%
  5. Which other country would you love to live in? oh, let me see. it HAS to be a place where the culture isn´t that different than mine. i´ve been to Switzerland and it´s beutiful but i would die bored if i´d live there! Brazil is great, specially for the nature factor. and i just love their culture and their way of living. but i guess i will die here in Argentina. for me there´s no better place to be inspite of all our troubles. :thumb:
0 likes
  1. Best - the very start, the first few notes.
  2. Worst - recycled sequencer bassline from State of the Nation.
  3. Love/hate - not sufficiently inspiring to trigger much reponse here.
  4. Third favourite off Technique, solid 50%
  5. Part of me would love to jack the London ratrace in and move to Antigua, and just play music to keep my head above water while relaxing. Failing that, I'd move to Paris or Antwerp, both great cities of culture. I'd miss England though, shithole or no shithole. My hands are a bit tied on this, the missus refuses to live outside England !
0 likes
  1. Whispery bit at the end, much parodied round these parts! (what was it Tim? "Burslem, Hamley and Trenty Vale too, I've been to all those places but never sniffed glue!")
  2. It's a bit cheesy (I know that's the point, but....)
  3. Like most of the heavily sequenced numbers on "Technique", it does seem hermetically sealed in 1989, but a killer chorus and plenty of happy memories mean that this one gets thumbs up from me!!
  4. 75%
  5. "In my mind I live in California".
0 likes
  1. Best - been listening to it live for the first time in donkey's recently, after getting Alex's mixers and the vocoder voice in the middle with the lyrics not on Technique get me every time.
  2. Worst - cheesy and a bit 'clumpy', not very well structured.
  3. Love/hate - it's okay, solid and dependable but nothing special. Much like the rest of Technique.
  4. 60%
  5. House-hunting out of town at the mo' and it's a struggle to imagine living anywhere other than London, let alone England. Am faaaar too English in my ways and my likes, and would miss the culture. Would probably have to opt for Noo Yoik or Sydney, but they're too isolated from home, so would probably plump for Holland or Denmark, maybe Sweden. Germany at a push.
0 likes

Originally posted by Al Jarvis 1. Best - been listening to it live for the first time in donkey's recently, after getting Alex's mixers and the vocoder voice in the middle with the lyrics not on Technique get me every time.

Everyone's had these mixers but me, and I was the first to pay for them !!!

0 likes

Originally posted by Reg Bumswizle > Originally posted by Al Jarvis 1. Best - been listening to it live for the first time in donkey's recently, after getting Alex's mixers and the vocoder voice in the middle with the lyrics not on Technique get me every time.

Everyone's had these mixers but me, and I was the first to pay for them !!!

He must be doing loads of stuff for people - I got another half-dozen gigs through on Saturday from him, about three weeks after I received what I thought was all the stuff I'd ordered initially.

0 likes

Originally posted by Al Jarvis > Originally posted by Reg Bumswizle> > > > Originally posted by Al Jarvis> 1. Best - been listening to it live for the first time in donkey's recently, after getting Alex's mixers and the vocoder voice in the middle with the lyrics not on Technique get me every time.

Everyone's had these mixers but me, and I was the first to pay for them !!!

He must be doing loads of stuff for people - I got another half-dozen gigs through on Saturday from him, about three weeks after I received what I thought was all the stuff I'd ordered initially.

Count yerself lucky - I ain't had the ones I paid thirty quid for a month ago yet. If you don't want any of them, bung 'em my direction !

0 likes
  1. The best bit - Bernard's beginning vocal, i.e., "How can I..."
  2. The worst bit - the whole song is ace! Many people don't like it, but I think it's a great song.
  3. Why you love/hate it - I love it because it reminds me of a love song :love2:
  4. A percentage rating - 80%
  5. Which other country would you love to live in? Would love to live in my father's home land...Merry 'Ole England.
0 likes
  1. Drum drops at the beginning then that wonky bass. Instant love.
  2. That the song bloody ends. It's one of those New Order tracks I never, ever get sick of.
  3. I rather relate to it. And it's beautifully produced, with all of the New Order pieces fitting together perfectly. It's a sad dance song, too, which rates highly with me.
  4. 100%. My favorite New Order track.
  5. I like America just fine, but would like to spend an extended visit in the UK.
0 likes
  1. The whispery bit
  2. The cheesy sound effects
  3. Weakest song on technique for me
  4. 80%
  5. Luxembourg
0 likes

best part--the chorus, almost emotional worst--cheesy techy sounds dnk donk, dink dink doick why I love it--emotions, a catchy tune that I can sing 80% I live in the Land of the Wierd and cheap gas, why move anywhere else? Germany I suppose so I do some high speed runs on the Autobahn and kill myself as well as the family in the Peugot I just creamed. :nonono:

0 likes

1.The synth-horns at the beginning!The sequenced background beeps! 2. I can't find anything wrong with that song. Sure, it stole SOTN's bassline, but I'd say that it's much, much better than that song. 3.It's just such a well-done song; I can't explain it, really. It's also a nice seque from Guilty Partner and Run to Vanishing Point._ 4.85%-90% 5.Your country is a wonderful place, it pales my Eng...er...New York into disgrace.

0 likes

Best things are that it's a decent tune, and I like Barney's singing on this one.

Don't care much for the beginning of the instrumental section, nor for the song title itself.

It's not my fave song on Technique, but I never pull the needle off the vinyl whenever I play it.

Rating 75%

Suppose somewhere in Western Europe would be the place to be for a Yank.

0 likes

best bit: I like the little background melody going on in the chorus and the "Barcelona" and "Ibiza" samples in the live versions worst bit: the end where it goes into vanishing point love/hate: I like this song quite a bit actually. Probably in my top 15 NO songs. Alternates with Dream Attack as my favorite from Technique. Country I would like to live in: There's a lot of cities that I'd love to maintain an apartment in (Paris, London, Sydney, San Francisco) but I think as far as a culture (the people, the food, the pace) that I could really embrace, I think Spain is a place I could really settle into. I found it be quite charming as well as sophisticated when I was there.

0 likes

[ Hi Nicolas do You recieve the video?

0 likes

Originally posted by Denial_1963 [Hi Nicolas do You recieve the video?

Yes, I got it last friday, finally!

Thank you, I didn't watch it yet...

0 likes

I remember seeing em start with Mr Disco at the SECC in 1989. Lost me shoe down the front.

I was wearing the BLOGGS fawn coloured long sleeve shirt.

God I thought I was cool

Mike

0 likes

The best bit: Chorus & synth in the chorus and the beginning. The worst bit: Its name Why you love/hate it: I love it because it's a good techno track, could have better bass usage, but I think it was not the point. A percentage rating: 85% Which other country would you love to live in?: France would be the obvious choice.. as I'd probably have a hard time to adapt to another language in every day's life..

BTW, what's so cheesy about Mr Disco?

0 likes
  1. The lyrics, Barney's voice, the fact it's so damn catchy.
  2. I started unintentionally singing this at work in the summer, and it was pretty embarassing.
  3. Barney's voice just sounds good here, and I actually like the title. Unfortunately, it's one of those songs I don't want to be caught singing in public.
  4. 90%
  5. Any place but the Ukraine or Russia, since I'd probably get arrested in either.
0 likes
  1. The lyrics and the synths.
  2. That there was never a single release or mixes.
  3. One of my fave tracks, it relates to my past memories of a particular someone.
  4. 95%
  5. Somewhere in England, or Ireland.
0 likes

Well every country has its low points i guess: Ireland and the UK have their weather, the US have bush jr :laugh:, Argentina have a dangerous lunatic coachin their football team :D and Greece has greeks :laugh: :p . In the end i cant be sure ( i do remember though, when i visited Ireland i tried really hard to convience myself to get up the the plane that would fly me back ;) ). Awwww i forgot this thread is about mr. disco :scratch: . Hmmmm 85 % it is for me :) .

0 likes
  1. Lyrics and vocals
  2. lame song title but nothing else really
  3. Love it
  4. 100% without a doubt
  5. Spain
0 likes

Best Bit: The synth/drum patters are excellent, especially that stereo effect in the middle of the song. Worst Bit: They repeat the chorus after that amazing electronic noise in the middle. They should extend that out, and end w/ the "Ibeza, etc." whispers. Why I love/hate: First proper Order LP I got into, lots of good memories of high school and my first car. Top song Rating: 99.999% Country: CANADA :D

0 likes
  1. Best bit: The vocals
  2. Worst bit: When it ends
  3. Why I love it: A great song from a great album
  4. Percentage rating: 90%
  5. Other country I'd like to live in: Probably Italy
0 likes
  1. when i skip over it
  2. all of it
  3. it further sinks Technique into unlistenable territory.
  4. 2%
  5. England or Spain
0 likes

One of my personal New Order favorites!!!:clap:

0 likes

Originally posted by Spotnick This week's review is.. Mr Disco1. The best bit2. The worst bit3. Why you love/hate it4. A percentage rating5. Which other country would you love to live in?So here you go, it's up to you! answer any question you want!

question 5 New York, Turkey again, Cuba

0 likes

Best Bit:

That instrumental bridge in the middle. Love the synths in there. Also love the lyrics following that, "Maybe you could write me a letter...", cribbed the lyrics in a letter and won a girl's heart with them. We lasted seven years :). 1990-1997

Worst Bit:

The title. One of the worst ever New Order titles though maybe it makes sense (in keeping with their intentions for the song), still, at least it's not as bad as 60 MPH. What's that supposed to mean? You're a wild one, except that old ladies riding in larks would pass you on a highway?

Why I love it?

Musically I find it both gorgeous, and very stimulating, usually New Order songs this gorgeous are more stately (Thieves, Age of Consent, Your Silent Face, Elegia), but this combines beauty and intensity. Barney's singing is outstanding as well and I do like the lyrics as well. It's perfect.

Other Country I'd like to live in: I'm happy where I am. However if I could spend some open ended time anywhere, it would probably be Italy, and I wouldn't mind logging a lot of time in Brazil either :D.

0 likes
  1. Best bit: Catchy chorus
  2. Worst bit: When it ends
  3. Why I love it: Catchy and from Technique
  4. Percentage rating: 80%
  5. Other country I'd like to live in: Japan; for all the high tech stuff :)
0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗