Ok, if this poll has been done before I'm sorry. Its my first try. I've heard they may get back together, I just wanted to see what everyone else thought. I think the should reform, and with all the original members. I also love the Second Coming album.
Dates
· UTC
Should the Stone Roses get back together?
Archived8 replies · 339 views
This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.
Should the Stone Roses get back together?
Closed-
Yes, all the original members 7 (78%)
-
Yes, but only John and Ian 0 (0%)
-
Yes, because I'm tired of Mani wasting his time in Primal Scream 0 (0%)
-
Yes, but with Maddix on drums 0 (0%)
-
Yes, because I loved the Second Coming 0 (0%)
-
No, because I hated the Second Coming 2 (22%)
-
No, because Ian and John's solo stuff is very good as it is 0 (0%)
-
No, the Sea Horses should though 0 (0%)
9 votes · voting closed
← Back to Behind Closed Doors
9 posts
I think I'd like to be the attorney for the bouncer that cunt Ian Brown cold-cocked in San Francisco. 
The Seahorses were a travesty.
The Roses should come back together only after Brown has the crap beaten out of him and is taught how to sing in tune once more. Otherwise I think a Smiths reunion is more likely.
Interesting. Funny though, a smiths reunion would be great too! But will never happen. Ian's ego is a bit big right now, he may be the one to blame currently if the roses don't come back together soon. I remember hearing that John Squire wanted to make peace with Ian, plus record some new material. Oh well, who knows. And he does need some singing lessons aswell,
. Although, I would really like to hear them do atleast one more song, even if Ian never learns to sing in tune, maybe a new verison of Elepahnt. Man, even a live gig with all the together would be great.
Neither a Smiths reunion or a Stone Roses reunion is ever happening.
We have had this conversation before. It was about a year ago, and there was a rumour that the Roses were reforming to play move 2004. Pity it never happenned but what can you do.
Anyway, a Roses reunion would be the biggest cash in ever. The magic disappeared after 1991, after that they were just another band. They were sort of like a pre cursor to oasis, amazing songs at the start, and then tailed off. Ian Brown now sells out everywhere he plays, but only because he plays the Old Roses songs. Theres a lesson in that.
yes i hope they will one day get back together again,maybe if they get a big money deal from somewhere they might reform..
Dunno if it would work out, with Ian and John not talking to one and other,but i'd love it if they could sort it out.Their music together is something i and all my mates will always treasure...I loved this band like I do new order.
