Diamond White wrote:
J.A.K wrote:
Uncle Liam wrote:
steveone wrote:
If Marr,Rourke and Joyce are there then count me in. 
Why would anyone want Marr over Jesse Tobias?
Rourke over Gary Day?
and Joyce over Matt Walker?

Coz they were the Smiths.
and Smiths beat Morrissey any day of the work, err week.
aahhh, yer too young to know.


I don't really have an opinion about the rest of the band, but I just don't agree that any of the post-Smiths guitarists have held a candle to Marr.
I thought this was most obvious when I was sober and stood right next to Jesse* when he tried to do a couple of Smiths songs in Dundee. Just nowhere near the level of skill of Marr.
I was really disapointed in Boz Boorer on the two dates I saw - he didn't play half as well as I thought he would. His best performance was tapping a glass of water, drinking some then tapping it again.
Someone was playing excellent rockabilly guitar on the early post-Smiths material, but that was just one side of Marr. I've never heard anoyone match Morrissey's lyrics and voice as well as Marr, and a lot of Mozz's solo work cries out for him to join in.
Still, it's the best we can do for now. I hope to be there for these gigs.
*Assuming Jesse is that Spanish-looking guiratist that plays with Mozz now?
Absolutely- saw Mozza at the apollo this year as well as Marr doing the Manc v Cancer show in January. Marr blew Morissey's version of How Soon is Now of the stage. Moz is good but with Marr he is great.