Originally posted by Oh Look! There Goes The Laughing Martian Again!!
> Originally posted by Fingers> > > > Originally posted by Oh Look! There Goes The Laughing Martian Again!!> > > > > > > Originally posted by Fingers> > > I had just started to look through my CD collection for inspiration when I remembered what my answer to the question is: it's "Wouldn't It Be Nice" by The Beach Boys. > > > Why? "Pet Sounds" is my favourite album and "Wouldn't It Be Nice" is my favourite track on the album.> > > > > > If I read through the track listing of every CD in my collection I may find a single song on another album that I prefer but I really doubt it because I think "Wouldn't It Be Nice" is about as close as it is possible to get to musical and lyrical perfection. There's nothing in it that could be improved in any way, from the deceptive intro through the exquisite harmonies, the magical orchestration and the slowing-down build-up to the last verse to the lullaby singing in the fade out. Threaded into this are the most child-like but worldly-wise lyrics, sung with real emotion. Actually, it's not close to perfect - it is perfect.> > >
Pet Sounds. Ahhhh.... I know everybody goes on about it in those tedious lists, but it really is a fine record indeed - so concise too (just under 32 minutes). Believe me, some of those songs make me tearful cos the arrangements are so goddamned BEAUTIFUL. (it's not often an instrumental (track 6) can have that effect either, come to think of it!)
Now, if you want to hear what a modern equivalent of this record sounds like, check out "Hawaii" by The High Llamas - truly, unutterably scrumptious....

Thanks for the recommendation Marty and here's one in return. "Let It Come Down" by Spiritualized is in the same league as "Pet Sounds" (which is the "is there any way this album could have been improved league?"). It's better than "Different Class", "Screamadelica" and even "OK Computer". If you need any more persuading tell me and I'll rave about it at greater length.
Yep - got that too - Bought it when it was released as I like Spiritualized - and yes, what a truly UPlifting record that is! Especially the BeachBoys pastiche "Do It All Over Again" - their most blatanly pop moment. The only gripe I had with this otherwise very fine record is Jason's deadpan nasal vocals tend to grate after a while...they do the ambitiously grandiose arrangements no favours...but only a minor gripe nevertheless.....

Sorry Marty but I can't agree with you about Jason's vocals on "Let It Come Down". He may not the world's best singer but his vocals suit the songs perfectly. When the lyrics are scornful so is his vocal. When the lyrics are guilt-laden so is his vocal. When the lyrics are tender so is his vocal. Given a choice between a singer who can do anything with their voice but doesn't sound like they mean what they're singing and a singer who is, to be blunt, limited but sings with genuine feeling I would choose the latter every time.
If my argument hasn't convinced you just think about JD's "Love Will Tear Us Apart". Ian's vocals suit the sentiments of the lyrics perfectly and if he had sung the song in any other way it wouldn't have been as good as the version we know and love. The same can be said for Paul McCartney on The Beatles' "Yesterday", Michael Stipe on R.E.M.'s "Everybody Hurts", Keith Flint on The Prodigy's "Firestarter" (I know I've made one hell of a leap there but trust me) and pretty much every track on "Pet Sounds" or "Let It Come Down". When a singer gets a song (and it's usually one of their own songs) absolutely right there's no way any No.1 hit-seeking pop group, lazy bandwagon-chasing dance producer or contestant on Pap Idol can improve upon the original.