Feeling Guilty
Archived32 replies · 1,386 views
Michael Monkhouse wrote: Is it true they've added GIAUE to the setlist? If so, is it any good live?
Sounds exactly like it did on the record.
To quote Jarvo in Wolves "that is a shit song" 
Well, it's not that bad, but I must admit that Who's Joe is a much better live song... this one is a keeper and should open the gigs.
I don't think it sounds exactly like on the record. Hooky's bass can be heard actually and I think it's fantastic. On a scale of 1 to 10, I rate it 8
Better than Wftsc. It's maybe not their best track but at least it's a change to the standard choices. I certainly enjoyed it 
Yeh I think it will get better with time. I do think that it is good already. As a whole they got better as the tour went on. But as always there are a few dodgy Bernard moments , but hey thats whey we love them. You are just to critical Jarvo. And how can you evaluate them from the bar?? Meow!
reg wrote: You are just to critical Jarvo. And how can you evaluate them from the bar?? Meow!
That's not being too critical. I just think it's a shit song. The Mac Quayle thing had some bollocks, but this is just way too lightweight and trite.
Can't all like the same song (G)Reg? 
I like what Hooky adds to the live version but i wouldn't be sad if they don't play it again at gigs.Much prefer Who's Joe
Well, I liked it when the "album" came out, and I love hearing it live...but then, I'm retarded like that...
El Jarvo wrote:
reg wrote: You are just to critical Jarvo. And how can you evaluate them from the bar?? Meow!
That's not being too critical. I just think it's a shit song. The Mac Quayle thing had some bollocks, but this is just way too lightweight and trite.
Can't all like the same song (G)Reg?
(G)reg right on kid:)
Don't get me wrong, I love the original, but I believe they should try some other live, like Morning Night and Day... that would sound great live, I'm sure of it.
But I admit they are getting better with Guilt.. it was horrible in Blackpool, it sounded fine at wembley.
Not one of my favourite album tracks, but live I think it works, it has that roughness that Close Range had live which I quite like.
Any time a new track is added to the setlist we should be thrilled. Beggars can't be choosers. Would you prefer they bring Run Wild back instead?
Just thank God that they didn't play Jetstream :)
I think Gulit is an excellent song, live and on record. I would like to hear Morning Night and Day live to!
I like the record versions of Guilt, but it doesn't work live for me. Too much guitar and bass, I suppose they have to give Phil and Hooky something to do!
I really like it as a tune on the album and on the strength of the US promo mixes it's a shame it missed out on being a single. Trite chorus but the lyrics don't count for everything I suppose, especially with New Order.
It has to be said when they played it at Glasgow on the second night I went to the bar. From what I could see it's not a million miles away from Roger Lyons popping in a CD of the instrumental (Note: I didn't actually see this) and Barney doing karaoke over the top I.e. not quite live?
Of course even if it is a bit limp it's nice to seem them do something - anything - new.
Far better than Atmosphere for the 5 millionth time
It does have a bad karaoke feel to it, yes! Guess it's probably on Roger's laptop rather than a CD but besides that you could well be absolutely spot-on!
Uncle Liam wrote: Bernard dances like he is the pipettes or something...
Not a bad thing, surely??!!
Andy wrote: Any time a new track is added to the setlist we should be thrilled. Beggars can't be choosers. Would you prefer they bring Run Wild back instead?
Guilt is a Useless Live Track. Love it on the album, but can't see the point of it live. Most of it's taped anyway and we get enough of Barney's dancing in BLT.
Hopefully they won't do it again.
I used to think that the day would never come, but I was actually glad to hear True Faith by the end of the tour!
Run Wild would be fine if Barney could manage to sing it without sounding like he's had a stroke.
* See Hyde Park 2005
Never cared for the album version overly, t'was OK at Wembley, nothing amazing, but fair play to them for trying something new, slowly but surely more and more of WFTSC is getting an outing, some works, some doesn't...Hopefully they might work out what's good live and keep it, bin the rest and then just bring back Hurt... 
Snorri xxx
Should/could they have done the Mac Quayle mix live?
It's really an alternative album version rather than a full on remix to my ears. There's some new Hooky bass in there plus some funky guitar for Phil to grapple with. Both left out of Stuart Price's version for some strange reason.
And as Al pointed out, it has some bollocks
