Tibet House NYC GIG

SO who went to this and what was the setlist.

Can't see Gillian, and drummer doesn't look like Steve - anyone know what the score there is?

Some videos on YouTube with Iggy including California Grass (!!) - who saw that one coming??

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2IGDC9vzmHM&list=UUI4GCwKTmWxE6F5TQQCIMFw

LWTUA with Iggy:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OoQq4MWJL-A&list=UUI4GCwKTmWxE6F5TQQCIMFw

Transmission with Iggy

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZYEg01Iz2Fw&list=UUI4GCwKTmWxE6F5TQQCIMFw

St Antony with Mike Garry (Manchester Poet), a tribute to Tony Wilson, NO playing Your Silent Face

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HopbDkwYVrY&list=UUI4GCwKTmWxE6F5TQQCIMFw

Mmm - looking at Setlist FM this appears to be the sum total of the show!

New Order set was a disappointment. It should have been labeled Barney, Phil and Hook wannabe. One true member doesn't make it a new order concert. I was there and was disappointed. Iggy was ok, would rather have seen him sing one of his classics with NO then doing California Grass. And does Barney know any other JD songs besides LWTYAA and Transmission? I feel like I've seen him do those two 10000 times.

Did Hooky give you guys a tenner to post here?

I was at the gig. It was a massive success and the members of New Order who performed were massively received by the crowd, and the press reviews were uniformly positive.

Everyone is allowed their own opinions, of course, but you are a but late in the game with this one...this happened over a month ago.

By the way, Phil has been a member of New Order since 2004 (that's ten years) and has been playing with the band since 2001. Tom is doing a fine job for what is a pretty difficult task, which is taking over bass from the the Bass God Hooky.

Hooky left, the band continued on, get over it.

Was this genuinely labeled as being a 'New Order' concert though?

I presume not.

It's also ridiculous if this appears on setlist.fm as 'New Order' - the Bad Lootenant live line-up boasted more members of 'New Order' than this Tibet gig did.

Excellent point, Al. It was labelled as "New Order" or "Members of New Order".

The fact is...most of the groups appearing were not full groups. The National was billed as "The National", for instance, but not all members of the National were there.

There were definitely a lot of people in the crowd for New Order though, they got one of the biggest responses of the night, even if they were just cheering for Bernard. Technically though, New Order now consists of Tom and Phil as well as The Other Two. The fact that the new lineup is writing and recording together solidifies that.