most depressing Joy Division song?

What is the most depressing JD song?

I would say either Twenty-Four Hours, Decades, The Eternal, or IALP. Thoughts?

The entire second Peel Session, in particular Colony. So desolate...

Having recently spent hour after hour singing 24 Hours and Passover, I'd choose either of those. The lyrics are just so desperate, particularly 24 Hours.

all of them

24 Hours and Sound of Music from the second Peel session...though I find them more desperate than depressing.

Hey, I've just become a member of the Republic!

You've just won a Phil Collins albums collection for this fact

I Remember Nothing,Auto-Suggestion and In a Lonely Place in my opinion.

Originally posted by Brazil Order You've just won a Phil Collins albums collection for this fact

Why would I want one of those? Or do you think I've never heard that 'witticism' before?

I've lost control again

SHELLSHOCK....shit wrong band!;)

I almost forgot Something Must Break. That's up there, too.

really depressive???

Decades Just one of my favorite songs!

Insight

New Dawn Fades

<--me when i hear it

COLONY

This one is really very depressive.:(

24 hours and The Eternal.

Decades is damn depressing; if I listen to it in the middle of the day I feel like going ot sleep right after, or go do something to cheer me up, like watch TV

Originally posted by Deadly Viper Assassination Squad Decades is damn depressing; if I listen to it in the middle of the day I feel like going ot sleep right after, or go do something to cheer me up, like watch TV

My sister asked me once who died when I was listening to it in 1990

It'll be between The Eternal and Decades.

The demo version of In a lonely place on Heart and Soul

Song - In A Lonely Place

Venue - Boston Sept 1980

CREEPY!

shes lost control, atmosphere and the whole warsaw RCA album :D

Funky Cold Medina....oh, wrong artist

I'd say 24 Hours or The Eternal, both are pretty bleak lyrically

Damn Trevor you are more depressing than JD, I applaud your talent

"The Eternal" has to be the most depressing JD song but also very beautiful. That piano coupled with Ian's slow singing is enough to give me goosebumps. "Decades" would be second perhaps tied with "Atmosphere". I love them slow JD songs. :D

One track i forgot, I Remember Nothing.

Passover and Love Will Tear Us Apart.

Originally posted by Some Distant Memory "The Eternal" has to be the most depressing JD song but also very beautiful. That piano coupled with Ian's slow singing is enough to give me goosebumps. "Decades" would be second perhaps tied with "Atmosphere". I love them slow JD songs. :D

SF ;LJA

Totally agree, 'The Eternal' is a song to slit your wrists and has me questioning the sanity of the writer....poor fellow.

Colony is the most utterly depressive JD song for me. Chainsaw guitar sound, repetative bass and drum loop, very harsh and bleak sound. At least 24 Hours, The Eternal and Decades all have melodies and some beautiful music.