Personally, I loved the multicolored bar motif of the Get Ready-era releases. It had a very clean, contemporary look that fit very well with the music. I also love sheer pretentiousness, so I guess that kind of explains it... :)
I think that the reason why the Krafty cover is so controversial is simply because, unlike previous New Order releases, many have heard the song before seeing the cover; as a result, Saville's artwork hasn't been given the chance to influence one's visualization/impression of Krafty. Nobody has had the chance to connect the cover to the music.