Skip to content

Manchester Evening News Review: Track by track

Archived

18 replies · 868 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

New Order – Waiting For The Sirens’ Call - track by track review ![3star](http://www.manchesteronline.co.uk/img/3star.gif)

Paul Cockerton

| | | --- |

| |

Who’s Joe? – 4/5

Kicks off with some mournful strings like Ian Brown's F.E.A.R., but Who's Joe? soon turns into jangly indie/electro New Order straight from their Republic period. There’s a catchy as hell guitar and bass interlude towards the end which suggests this could be the next single, which would make it the first and last dreamy pop song about a tramp to hit the charts.

Hey Now What You Doing? – 3/5 Continues in the same vein as the opener until a rather introspective chorus kicks in. Barney daringly tries to rhyme ‘future’ with ‘computer’ while new guitarist Phil pops up and smears a dirty guitar solo over the middle bit.

Waiting For The Sirens’ Call – 3/5

Barney says it’s about death or infidelity, but you'd never notice as he sings with such wide-eyed wonder and the song is wrapped up in such a sugary coating. It clocks in at nearly six minutes, while throughout Hooky’s bass sounds like it’s about to break into Monaco’s What Do You Want From Me?

Krafty – 4/5

Lead single and by far the most euphoric moment on the album. Barney starts out all depressed at the mundanity of working life, but then the xylophones kick in, followed by a monster bass solo, and suddenly there’s a cheesy grin slapped across his face. Krafty's nowhere as immediate as Crystal, the opening single from last album Get Ready, but it does grow on you quicker than a particularly virulent dose of athlete’s foot.

I Told You So – 2/5

It’s taken New Order 25 years to incorporate dancehall rhythms into their sound, and after hearing I Told You So you’d wish they’d waited another few decades. It’s like early nineties dub dance acts like Leftfield and Bomb The Bass in chill-out mode. The very definition of an album filler.

Morning Night And Day – 4/5

Straight after the lowest point on the record comes one its highest peaks. Morning Night And Day could be the finest five-minute electropop ode to hangovers in the world - ever. Built around an almost endless loop of keyboard noises and a great chorus, it's another potential single.

Dracula’s Castle – 3/5

It was written in a courthouse built for Henry VIII, so as you can imagine there’s quite a sombre, vaguely spooky vibe to it. It’s the closest they get to Joy Division on the album, all brooding bass and guitar parts, though there’s lots of squelchy synth noises too for the last few minutes.

Jetstream – 3/5

Starts off plodding and lethargic, but leave that skip button alone. The nagging melody starts to make sense by the time Scissor Sisters’ Ana Matronic drifts in to add her vocals. Not a highlight by any means, but there’s something maddeningly infectious about the way the pair sing "da da na na na na" at the end like it's a twisted nursery rhyme.

Guilt Is A Useless Emotion – 4/5

The second track on the album with Les Rhythmes Digitales’ Stuart Price in the producer’s chair, and as you might expect, the most overtly Eighties track on the album. The beats pulse and surge, weaving in and out of some digitised handclaps, while Ana Matronic's breathy Kylie-style backing vocals fade in and out. Pure pop.

Turn – 3/5

Set to be a permanent fixture on drivetime radio, Turn is relentlessly upbeat with big cascading guitars jangling throughout. But it's masking a rather downcast message - "Turn your eyes from me," insists a subdued Barney. Intriguing.

Working Overtime – 4/5

And now for something completely different. This could have been on The Stooges self-titled album or The Beatles' Revolver, or indeed on any modern day Primal Scream album. Vintage guitar fuzz of the highest order and quite unlike anything New Order have put their name to before.

Overall verdict

Four different producers contributed to the 11 tracks but Waiting For The Sirens' Call still flows surprisingly well. There are at least three more potential singles waiting to follow Krafty into the top ten in Working Overtime, Guilt Is A Useless Emotion, and Morning Night And Day. But more significantly, the album as a whole improves with every listen.

What's your favourite track on the album? Have your say.

0 likes

What is wrong with these people? Are they deaf?

0 likes

'Manchester' Evening News.

Is that based in Manchester?

'... but Who's Joe? soon turns into jangly indie/electro New Order straight from their Republic period ...'

Rhubarb! ... Rhubarb!

0 likes

Anna provides backing on Guilt Is A Useless Emotion?

She's previously only been credited on Jetstream I thought :confused:

0 likes

There's so many holes in that review it's like a snooker table.

DoN - send them your review and ask them to retract the newspaper.

0 likes

DoN wrote:

Anna provides backing on Guilt Is A Useless Emotion?

She's previously only been credited on Jetstream I thought :confused:

I doubt she is, although if it's Dawn Zee, she doesn't sound like her other backing vocals... but it does seem like a black female, isn't it? (nothing bad with it, just the type of voice)

0 likes

I read that the backing vocals were sung by The Weather Girls.

I know it sounds far fetched but I think its true.

0 likes

huntsman wrote: I read that the backing vocals were sung by The Weather Girls. I know it sounds far fetched but I think its true.

I think you're pulling our leg on this one, H.

0 likes

huntsman wrote: I read that the backing vocals were sung by The Weather Girls. I know it sounds far fetched but I think its true.

The weather girls or the cheeky girls?! :evil4:

0 likes

It was in the Manchester Evening News - and they're never wrong.

0 likes

Of course he is... plus, anybody could recognize Martha Wash's voice from a mile... that woman has probably the strongest voice I've heard in my life...

Remember all the Black Box and C+C Music Factory crap where they hired model to mime on Martha's vocals ;)

0 likes

I'm glad people weren't generally as cruel about my review - the M.E.N. might be 'inaccurate' but people are entitled to their opinions, even if they are wrong... :laugh:

0 likes

Actually the scores are about the same I have given, except the title track got a 5/5 and Working Overtime a 3/5

I just don't get why the title track got a so bad review, it's so beautiful...

0 likes

Fair enough Nic, but that just goes to show - people have different opinions. Look how many people here disagree about loving/hating: Technique, Movement, Shellshock, Get Ready, Republic, State of The Nation, WIFM...

Oh, wait... ALL of us hate WIFM! :evil:

0 likes

well tbh im not bothered what any reviewer thinks of new order or the latest album,they have been  written off by the press and hailed as gods by the press so who cares,if YOU like the album thats all that matters and dont be bothered about some half witt tipper tappers opinion.

as for the backing on guilt is a useless emotion i may have the answer.

had this on on the way back home tonite with my daughter listening too,she piped up "whats gwen staffani doing on this cd?".

and i thought to myself hmmmmm i wonder,i know that she had a bit of a falling out with new order after they had worked on her cd and that they had all kissed and made up.

now had gwen done backing and it is her? or did she do backing and during the fall out they removed her backing track and put a soundalike in.???

0 likes

Interesting theory - I'll ask Gwen when I've untied her and removed the gag...

0 likes

There's no need for that, Chris. Really.

Please, don't.

Stuart Price did "Guilt is a useless emotion?" Well, it all makes sense now! Here's hoping he's at least partially responsible for the rest of the tracks that were held back for the next LP.

0 likes

For me the title track is one of few highlights on what I think is their most dissapointing album to date. None of the tracks really stand out and make me want to play them over and over again like on previous albums. Its just not growing on me at all and 'Jetstream' makes me cringe. Most of its drive time Radio 2 music - still its all about opinions.

0 likes

I've listened to it a couple of times, and right now I agree with the general sentiment of the reviews, if not the particulars (on what songs are unusually good and unusually mediocre). My reaction has been very similar to my reaction to Get Ready and to a lesser extent Republic. Upon the initial listenings, I've felt that there is nothing particularly bad, not on the scale of some of the disastrous results unleashed on Republic. But even Republic had Regret, and Special, two moments that could stand toe to toe with nearly the whole New Order Oeuvre, neither Get Ready, nor Siren have those moments in my view. To be sure, there are songs that strike me as very good, if not quite classics. Sirens, Krafty (which is a grower), Guilt..., Turn, but many of the others are just middling or slightly above the average decent song you hear on the radio. As something from New Order, they are treasures, but rightly, by an unbiased observers ears, they'll sound like solid songs, if not special.

Maybe I'll agree with Spotnick, back when I was 14 and 15, it took me months and months to be charmed by Substance, and then even longer to grasp what made side 2 of Technique, as good as side one, but eventually I was wholly won over by both albums, maybe the same will happen with Sirens..., but somehow I think my reaction will be similar to mine to Get Ready. Years down the line, I'll listen and enjoy, but like Brotherhood, like Republic to an extent, and especially like Get Ready, I have doubts that this CD will become a treasured, and oft-played item on the scale that PCL, Low-Life, Technique and the Singles Collection "Substance" became. I'll be patient though, and considering that I gave all of the songs 7/10 or better, it's not as if I think it's a disappointment, it's just another album that by and large is lacking in the great heights, nearly all of the previous albums of the eighties have had.

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗