Skip to content

The Joy Division Cup - The Draw

Archived

90 replies · 2,842 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

This is the master list of the draw for the JD Cup.

Final Result Transmission 27-16 Twenty Four Hours

Semi Final Results

Transmission 23-22 Decades Insight 11-35 Twenty Four Hours

Quarter Final Results

Novelty 18-23 Insight Transmission 31-13 Dead Souls Atmosphere 21-22 Decades Digital 14-28 Twenty Four Hours

Third Round Results

The Eternal 11-33 Digital Insight 20-19 No Love Lost These Days 18-29 Novelty Atmosphere 28-20 Heart And Soul Transmission 25-14 She's Lost Control Decades 21-17 Disorder Dead Souls 32-8 Something Must Break Day Of The Lords 5-32 Twenty Four Hours

Just how unlucky have Disorder and Transmission been so far in these draws? Couldn't get any harder!

Second Round Results

Atmosphere 18-17 New Dawn Fades Leaders Of Men 5-30 Decades Disorder 22-15 Shadowplay From Safety To Where? 5-29 Digital These Days 26-19 Interzone Transmission 25-24 Love Will Tear Us Apart Dead Souls 39-6 The Drawback Colony 19-25 No Love Lost Passover 13-23 Novelty A Means To An End 11-32 She's Lost Control The Eternal 27-15 The Only Mistake The Sound Of Music 6-35 Twenty Four Hours Glass 11-23 Insight Heart And Soul 29-7 Exercise One Something Must Break 30-5 As You Said The Kill 6-30 Day Of The Lords

A few interesting ones there then!


First Round Results

Ice Age 4-63 Love Will Tear Us Apart Transmission 47-19 Isolation As You Said bye Heart And Soul 57-9 Wilderness The Drawback bye New Dawn Fades bye Something Must Break bye Decades bye Incubation 5-58 Shadowplay A Means To An End 40-24 Warsaw The Kill bye I Remember Nothing 12-33 The Sound Of Music Disorder bye Digital bye Day Of The Lords bye Passover bye No Love Lost bye These Days 30-20 Komakino Twenty Four Hours bye Dead Souls bye Colony bye Glass bye Insight bye Interzone bye Exercise One 35-12 At A Later Date Leaders Of Men bye Failures Of The Modern Man 9-41 The Eternal From Safety To Where? 25-12 Autosuggestion She's Lost Control bye Atmosphere 32-10 Atrocity Exhibition Novelty 33-8 Candidate The Only Mistake 25-15 Walked In Line

0 likes

cool. :D Heart and Soul against Wilderness was the hardest of the lot today.

0 likes

I have done my duty :) Although tough one there between Isolation and Transmission but in the end decided to go with T.

0 likes

NObabe wrote: I have done my duty :) Although tough one there between Isolation and Transmission but in the end decided to go with T.

i agree; that was a tough one. but i also chose the latter.

0 likes

What if the votes are equal at the end of the poll?

0 likes

Then they go to 'extra time' then 'penalties' Johnny...

0 likes

What , no Golden goal then?:)

0 likes

and no cheating, FRANK! :evil4:

0 likes

AgentWood wrote: and no cheating, FRANK! :evil4:

Frank Smarra? Or Maya's Frank?:scratch:

0 likes

Confused even here :\ohwell:

0 likes

Johnny wrote:

AgentWood wrote: and no cheating, FRANK! :evil4:

Frank Smarra? Or Maya's Frank?:scratch:

frank smarra. being an argentina fan, he'll know what i mean. ;)

0 likes

Yeah i figured it was the Argentina thing in the end

0 likes

PeteZarustica wrote: where do I vote?

See those threads entitled "The JD Cup - First Round" that tell you which songs are in the match? It'll be there.

0 likes

Easiest one was LWTUA VS IA.

Hardest was Trans Vs Isol, but had to go with Isol

0 likes

Yeah, that was the beauty of The Fall Cup, sometimes there were some easy choices, and sometimes not, I for one don't even have Wings in my Top Ten (more like Top 15). Just slightly irritated in the JD Cup cause two of my very fave tracks went head to head straight off (Transmission v. Isolation)..:lol: Ah well.......

0 likes

So far all my votes are in the majority stream

0 likes

Good idea this TIM.Will you be doing a PERNOD CUP for NEW ORDER?:thumb:

0 likes

Nope, nothing here... is it a poll?

0 likes

PeteZarustica wrote: Nope, nothing here... is it a poll?

See this thread? Close it, and look approximately 14 threads below it in the list. There you will see the first five polls. And if you can't find those, then you probably wouldn't be able to choose one of the songs in any case, would you?

0 likes

sounds like a complete load of bollocks!:nod:

0 likes

it was reasonalby easy so far. i think i went with the majority vote on most songs. the next round is bound to be much tougher.

0 likes

Why are so many songs 'bye'...

:scratch:

It's a shame we don't have a rating scheme on NOOL pools; i.e. a score vote for poll options of 1-5 (1; very good, 2; good, 3; average, 4; bad 5; very bad. (Or Vice Versa) ); then we could have a much more detailed and interesting picture of what people think the best JD/NO songs are...

:shrug:

0 likes

You try working out a draw with 45 entries then that divides down to an even number.....

0 likes

:shrug:

0 likes

Only vote for IceAge is from me...

0 likes

oldmonkey wrote: You try working out a draw with 45 entries then that divides down to an even number.....

but 19?! not really getting it. it seems very random. explain yrself.

0 likes

45-19=26

26/2=13

13+19=32

32 is a factor of 2

QED

0 likes

jesse steichen wrote:

oldmonkey wrote: You try working out a draw with 45 entries then that divides down to an even number.....

but 19?! not really getting it. it seems very random. explain yrself.

Explain myself? Why? :finger:

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗