Skip to content

looking for a good laugh?...

Archived

39 replies · 1,031 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

....this should provide it...

1 The Smiths :skeptic: 2 The Beatles 3 Stone Roses :sleep: 4 David Bowie 5 Sex Pistols 6 :violent: Oasis 7 Radiohead 8 :violent: Paul Weller/The Jam 9 U2 :headoff: 10 Public Enemy 11 Happy Mondays 12 The Clash 13 :nonono: Nirvana 14 Elvis Presley 15 Joy Division 16 Blur 17 The Strokes :confused: 18 The Rolling Stones 19 The Verve 20 Bob Marley 21 The Fall 22 Prodigy 23 Velvet Underground 24 REM 25 Frankie Goes To Hollywood :sick: 26 Dexy's Midnight Runners 27 Beastie Boys 28 T. Rex 28= Jesus and Mary Chain 30 The Specials 31 Manic Street Preachers :moon: 32 Roxy Music 33 Pixies 34 Iggy Pop 35 The Pogues 36 Primal Scream 36= Frank Sinatra 38 Bob Dylan 39 Blondie 40 Eminem 41 Culture Club :lol: 42 Madonna 43 Marvin Gaye 44 Pulp 45 Michael Jackson 46 The Charlatans :skeptic: 47 Echo and the Bunnymen 48 The KLF 49 Neil Young 50 PJ Harvey

The above is apparently the definitive list of artists most influential on the NME (certainly not an accolade worth having, good thing too as theyve seen fit to ignore new order...hmm surely theyve had more front covers than the strokes? Fuck`s sake even menswear have managed that feat).

:hi: hello again by the way

0 likes

No Falco?! Might as well throw him in, that'd add some dignity to the proceedings!

0 likes

Originally posted by velocity girl :hi: hello again by the way

Have you got an absent note?

0 likes

WB VG :)

Just who the fuck are the NME ? If that list truly represents the 50 most influential artistes of all time, then I am Flavor Flav, Bagpuss and George Best all rolled into one huge cigar.

0 likes

Hey, check out VG's profile. She's a smokin' hottie.

0 likes

:love:

0 likes

Now VG much as I appreciate more girlies here I have to (only slightly mind) tut tut your posting. (Although I appreciate you didn't write it)

I WILL NOT have you ridiculing 26, 35 and 46! :nonono: you bad girl!

Dexy's - I have recently found I am not alone in their adoration

Pogues - Couldn't have a bad word said (apart from perhaps - "teeth"?)

Charlatans - along with the mighty Order they are pure Gods in my eyes, almost everything they've done is class, why only number 46? AND why no chuffing Order! :mad:

0 likes

That list is a load of ole bolocks;) Dunno who the fook had input on it - but they clearly want :violent: No JD/NO - fookin amazes me! Must say, I like a large percentage of the bands / artists named in the list - but the order of it astounds me - just one example - The Verve more influential than Bob Marley or Marvin Gaye or Dylan:lol: Blow me down and call me jennifer;)

0 likes

Like Shug I also like a quantity of those mentioned but I almost forgot to 'tut tut' the inclusion of the Jam. That's Entertainment...

Blur - just who did they influence? :nonono:

The Verve? - weren't they just copies of womething better?

0 likes

Mrs Monkey - not like The Jam? Difference of opinion here then;) Fookin love The Jam - fair enough - it's mainly the singles I enjoy (the albums are a bit heavy going) but with classics like Down in the tubestation, Strange town, Eton Rifles, Going Underground, Town Called Malice...... The Jam deserve their place in the list a lot more than some of the shite that is in there - ALRIGHT!!!!;)

0 likes

Even if you take the list for what it is (which is a list of the acts that influenced the NME most) it is highly questionable. The Strokes, The Verve, Frankie Goes To Hollywood, Eminem, Culture Club and The KLF haven't made enough of an impact on the music scene to merit sufficient coverage to get them into the Top 50 (and there's only one reason why The Strokes are on the list and that's because the NME wants to please them in the hope that they will invite their hacks to their next party). The Fall, The Jesus and Mary Chain and The Pogues may have been around longer but they've been too peripheral to merit sufficient coverage. The Velvet Underground and The Pixies should have been higher up the list given that most alternative bands are indebted in some way to at least one of them and the Manic Street Preachers probably should have been higher up too (although if any publication was obsessed with the Manics it was Melody Maker). I could go on pointing out other strange decisions (Blur higher than R.E.M.? Is this a joke?) but I think too much time has already been wasted on this pointless exercise.

Thanks for posting up the list, VG. You've saved me £1.50.

0 likes

Originally posted by Jennifer, what about no. 15, you drinking again :)

:lol: :clap: Alright smart arse - not seeing them in the Top 10 obviously put me in a blind rage;) I promise this will not happen again:evil4:

0 likes

Sorry Shuglet, you misunderstood my tutting! I am a huge Jam campaigner, I was tutting at the fact that VG had ridiculed them ( and I might add the profession I chose at age 4 - to marry Paul Weller) I had the red leather jacket and everything - where did I go wrong :cry:

0 likes

Apologies - yer doin pretty well missus - New Order / JD, a big Charlies fan, like the Jam, you have a car......do you own yer own place and do you support Celtic?;) :lol:

0 likes

I live in Tamworth (admittedly owning a property) do you think I know what football is? ;)

Other than that you've already seen/ met me so you know I'm not really a good prospect! :)

0 likes

Originally posted by Cheeky Monkey I live in Tamworth (admittedly owning a property) do you think I know what football is? ;)Other than that you've already seen/ met me so you know I'm not really a good prospect! :)

:lol: :clap: :lol: Yeah - yer gonna have to improve with yer alcohol tolerance;) I'm thinking of releasing a video called "14 days on the piss with The Shugster" it'll be a step by step guide, after 2 weeks intensive bevvying - you'll be able to hold the alcohol intake of a small 3rd world country:lol: Hangover Cure booklet supplied;)

0 likes

Drinking Technique a la Shug?

From what I've heard I'd do as well on my own! ;)

Only kidding petal, I'll await the hangover guide in the post. Promise I'll send the Charlies Pics on Thursday by the way as I'm not at work I can venture to the PO and get said parcel weighed. :)

0 likes

Originally posted by Cheeky Monkey Drinking Technique a la Shug?From what I've heard I'd do as well on my own! ;)Only kidding petal, I'll await the hangover guide in the post. Promise I'll send the Charlies Pics on Thursday by the way as I'm not at work I can venture to the PO and get said parcel weighed. :)

I was on ANTIBIOTICS:lol: look forward to seeing the piccies - cheers!

0 likes

Antibiotics my arse - for what exactly or don't I want to know :skeptic:

0 likes

At least the Beatles aren`t No. 1.

:clap:

0 likes

Well.. Joy Division is #15, so New Order is #15 too.. it would be unfair to seperate both groups..

0 likes

i'm not british, but my personal take on these stupid lists is that they mean squat! it's kinda silly knocking off someone's stupid idea of what's great, cuz in the end, their opinion really doesn't matter unless they have the authority and the credibility to make that judgement. otherwise, it's just a popularity contest that name drops some credible and somewhat obscure names to sound credible.

p.s. how come the majority of this list has british bands? did they forget the rest of the world?

0 likes

Originally posted by Fingers Thanks for posting up the list, VG. You've saved me £1.50.

And for saving me 10 minutes from reading it at the newstand.

0 likes

Saw it in the metro this morning. Rubbish list. IN fairness to the bunch of gimps it is the bands that have influenced THEM the most - i.e. taken up the most column space etc.

I don't think the Strokes are so shit hot they' should have taken up almost as much column inches in 18months than JD/NO have in 20 odd years.

NME=Losers

0 likes

I think they should have left spots 2 through 4 blank, just to leave proper space between the Smiths and all other bands...

My list:

  1. The Smiths
  2. Everyone else

It's short, simple, and pretty much reflects my listening habits as a shy, disassociated youth.

0 likes

WHERE ARE A FLOCK OF SEAGULLS?????? That hair must have had some influence on something!!!

0 likes

The list is mentioned in todays Metro.

According to the NME associate editor, Alex Needham, The Smiths were "Pop stars of depth and intelligence, a dream to write about and the band most closely wedded to our history"

so there you go. :\ohwell:

0 likes

DISCLAIMER: I'm still very cranky about not coming to London again this summer, so I'm just tweaking all of you Brits here.

WHERE ARE THE SPICE GIRLS?

Talk about influence! Jesus McFuck!

Imitators include All Saints, Dream, N*Sync, and many other all-girl groups. They starred in their own movie, Spice World, after about 10 minutes together. They had dolls made of them (my niece-in-law keeps a naked Baby Spice in a wicker basket...much as I might do). They've been linked to royalty in all sorts of tabloid rumors. They've been name-checked in songs by Sticky, Eminem, and others. They appear in the style guides of the venerable Times and Guardian newspapers so square old journos don't embarrass the country by screwing up their names in print.

Girl you know it's true...Spice Girls are the true number one. What say you?

0 likes

....but the NME have barely acknowledged their existence...and they're therefore not on the list

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗