Skip to content

Ian Curtis in top ten of 'right wing rockers'

Archived

22 replies · 3,397 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

"...10. Ian Curtis

The lead singer of Joy Divison - who is currently depicted in Anton Corbijn's biopic Control - helped Margaret Thatcher into power by voting Conservative in 1979, reportedly as a protest against the Labour government of James Callaghan."

http://observer.guardian.co.uk/omm/story/0,,2187755,00.html

He committed suicide 12 months later. Hmmmm... :\oops:

0 likes

Didn't Paul Weller vote Conservative in the late 70s?

0 likes

He did. That's why he did Red Wedge.

  1. Geri Halliwell

At the height of Girl Power, in 1996, the Spice Girls gave a Christmas interview to The Spectator , in which Geri revealed their true inspiration 'We are true Thatcherites,' she explained. 'Thatcher was the first Spice Girl, the pioneer of our ideology.'

:thumbdown: :brow:

0 likes

Who gives a flying f**k what people vote for, as long as their not extremist left/right/religion etc.. it dont matter. Curtis was nowt (politically speaking) compared to Weller who flipped sides in 78' and wrote fantastic songs (Smithers Jones/Sat.. Kids et al)and the Specials- we still love them regardless of our own political views. I always immensely enjoyed a Marxist far left band called McCarthy and thoroughly enjoyed their gigs even though politically what they said didnt sit well with me. I also (still do) go and see Anarchist bands such as Conflict et al cos i get a buzz off em simple as that. Distinctly remember discussing t-shirts £ profit with Steve Ignorant in late 80's - he was far from convincing in his justification. But i'll be fucked if i want anarchy. Only last month i managed to catch up with Penny Rimbald (Crass) who came up here for a arts event. Didn't agree with the communal far leftist animal lib shit he came out with but non-the-less i enjoy a bit of Nagassaki Nightmare!

0 likes

I am Liberal, but just because someone is conservative, that doesn't make them a bad person.

A good friend of mine is a bit conservative..he is more if a Libertarian, actually.....he is also very open minded, intelligent, well read, and a good guy. So, we get along quite well, though we do have different political views.

0 likes

Zachery Starkey wrote: I am Liberal, but just because someone is conservative, that doesn't make them a bad person.

The fellow who plays synth in my live band is a bit conservative..he is more if a Libertarian, actually.....he is also very open minded, intelligent, well read, and a good guy. So, we get along quite well, though we do have different political views.

Too right my man. I am an intelligent,nice guy and conservative too!

As it has been stated already who cares who he voted for although I expect that most muscians voted left wing in the past and still do today.:nod:

0 likes

sea sea seasider.. wrote:

Zachery Starkey wrote: I am Liberal, but just because someone is conservative, that doesn't make them a bad person.

The fellow who plays synth in my live band is a bit conservative..he is more if a Libertarian, actually.....he is also very open minded, intelligent, well read, and a good guy. So, we get along quite well, though we do have different political views.

Too right my man. I am an intelligent,nice guy and conservative too!

As it has been stated already who cares who he voted for although I expect that most muscians voted left wing in the past and still do today.:nod:

Exactly! I actually quite enjoy intelligent conservatives....its good to have an intelligent, friendly discussion over politics. Plus, I have friends and family who are conservative. I love them. We are human beings...we have far more in common than we do our political differences. We all know that most politicians are asses anyways.

You are right....I suspect that most musicians and artists vote to the Left. Hah hah. :)

0 likes

I think it's important to remember that the Labour government of the late seventies' inability to manage the unions almost brought Britain to it's economic knees in terms of strikes and the three day week. I'm no fan - even these days - of the Tories but at least they told the unions where to shove it and got the country back on some sort of even keel.

It's swings and roundabouts with any political system where parties having their time in the sun then fall from grace after a decade or so - see Mr Brown slipping down the opinion polls as we speak.

I couldn't really give a toss that Ian voted Tory to be honest... in context of the time period they must've seemed a perfectly reasonable alternative.

0 likes

Andrew Sayer wrote: Who gives a flying f**k what people vote for, as long as their not extremist left/right/religion etc.. it dont matter. Curtis was nowt (politically speaking) compared to Weller who flipped sides in 78' and wrote fantastic songs (Smithers Jones/Sat.. Kids et al)and the Specials- we still love them regardless of our own political views. I always immensely enjoyed a Marxist far left band called McCarthy and thoroughly enjoyed their gigs even though politically what they said didnt sit well with me. I also (still do) go and see Anarchist bands such as Conflict et al cos i get a buzz off em simple as that. Distinctly remember discussing t-shirts £ profit with Steve Ignorant in late 80's - he was far from convincing in his justification. But i'll be fucked if i want anarchy. Only last month i managed to catch up with Penny Rimbald (Crass) who came up here for a arts event. Didn't agree with the communal far leftist animal lib shit he came out with but non-the-less i enjoy a bit of Nagassaki Nightmare!

Mr A Sayer. the voice of reason. As usual.

0 likes

ally wrote:

I couldn't really give a toss that Ian voted Tory to be honest... in context of the time period they must've seemed a perfectly reasonable alternative.

Yes Alistair but plenty of people do think its important. Similar to the way that loads of people think its importatn that Hooky waves at them when he does a DJ set in front of 30 people.

0 likes

I saw that post and i must say it was so bad it made Alan "Paul" Kitching look positively intellectual.

Worst post ever? Certainly the most boring.

0 likes

:abovelol:

That doesn't make him right-winged, in my opinion. I couldn't give a fuck as to what he thought politically about anything. Besides, when I hear the word 'right-wing', it makes me think of extreme people, like George W Bush or any of those evangelical Christian people.

0 likes

Sub-Cultured*!* wrote: What???

Geri Halliwell ranked higher than Ian Curtis? ...And she's a rocker!

At least someone got the point I was trying to make.:nod:

0 likes

He was too.

What about this from one of the Girls Aloud: "I blame Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. We should lock up more people. I know prisons are full, just build more!"

I heard a song on the radio over the summer that was very right wing. A kind of pop-dub affair, very homophobic & mysogonistic. That kind of stuff is well taken off by the boyos from the flight of the Conchords: http://tinyurl.com/2hwaxt "Fast Forward Selechta"

So, now the Tories have gone all soft and squishy, believing all this climate change BS, who would Ian C vote for today? UKIP? BNP?

Only Liam, the oracle of reactionary Manchester can fill us in ;)

0 likes

Because Ian was an anticommunist.

0 likes

wot, no Jimmy Pursey or that twat from Skrewdriver?

0 likes

so voting for a mainstream party makes you a top right winger. :nuts:

0 likes

NOOLigan wrote: so voting for a mainstream party makes you a top right winger. :nuts:

If it's a right-wing party (as the Tories were once upon a time) then, er, yes. Shirley?

Bottom line will always be though, it's more the perception of the Nazi imagery that will leave people thinking JD/IC were right-wingers than whatever party they voted for.

0 likes

El Jarvo wrote:

NOOLigan wrote: so voting for a mainstream party makes you a top right winger. :nuts:

Bottom line will always be though, it's more the perception of the Nazi imagery that will leave people thinking JD/IC were right-wingers than whatever party they voted for.

At last someone nails it! :bow:

0 likes

I never thought Curtis was into football, let alone played it.

0 likes

leather_girl wrote:

Besides, when I hear the word 'right-wing', it makes me think of extreme people, like George W Bush or any of those evangelical Christian people.

right wing means fascist bastards to me. e.g the Tory scum. :laugh:

anyway, i'm voting Labour this time. :laugh:

0 likes

oldmonkey wrote:

El Jarvo wrote:

NOOLigan wrote: so voting for a mainstream party makes you a top right winger. :nuts:

Bottom line will always be though, it's more the perception of the Nazi imagery that will leave people thinking JD/IC were right-wingers than whatever party they voted for.

At last someone nails it! :bow:

no Siouxsie then?

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗