15 replies · 639 views
I have 'vidoe 586' on CD single and 12". On the 12" is an instrumental Bowie/Eno sounding track which, according to the NO discography is Joy Division's 'As You Said'. I have never read about this track, or seen it mentioned in any discographies for Joy Division. Any ideas what this recording is, and where it came from?
Regards, Andrew Morrison Email: morriso@btinternet.com ICQ No. 52250781 Website: http://www.trustnoone.org.uk
This track was recorded during "Closer" recording sessions at Britannia Row Studios, London, March 18-30, 1980 and it was produced by Martin Hannett as usual. This song can be found at "Substance" CD and "Heart & Soul" box set as well.
Further to Ricardo's answer, As You Said was originally released on the free Komakino flexi (fac 28) and is on the B-side after Incubation. It's not credited on the label. I have also heard it referred to as "And Then Again"
Cheers OLD BLUE..i will go and dust my copy of this and give it a play with a 6 inch nail! :D
Originally posted by Ricardo Fernandes Fish & Chips. Englishmen always eat fish & chips. :D
nope...om this particular day they had kidney pie...I got this from a good source...so do not doubt my word...
Originally posted by Rocket Mick Cheers OLD BLUE..i will go and dust my copy of this and give it a play with a 6 inch nail!:D
dammit Mick...do you ever sleep??? or are you an insomniac like myself? would you like a beer?
and by the way, I know where you can pick up a backpack, dirt cheap!!!!
well...i think i read something about "as you said"...something like it's a 2 minute snippet cut out of the original 21 minute recording of "5 8 6"...could that be right ??? 
cheers.
I'm not sure that is the case, Marco. Have you never heard As You Said? I could try and send you an MP3.
Originally posted by Old Blue I'm not sure that is the case, Marco. Have you never heard As You Said? I could try and send you an MP3.
hm..well, i have the "Heart & Soul" boxset. I'll give it another listen. I thought i read that in a biography of NewOrder/JoyDivision, i guess it was "Dreams Never End". Anyway, i'll check it ;)
Originally posted by Ricardo Fernandes Fish & Chips. Englishmen always eat fish & chips. :D
Even for breakfast, apparently. As was alleged to us in Germany for the Order last weekend. And we all have lots of tattoos. Although someone reckoned I was actually Scottish (Shug, please note) as I had 'tartan' shorts on and Jocks always wear tartan. Said shorts were actually Aquascutum.
fac 28 is flexi
there are no words to the song
definate hannett production
newOrder I think have egg mc Muffins dont they? but in reality, its a private affair what they have. The band members probably think that the people here are insane because , who really cares what they have for breakfast, as long as they dont get fatter. Stephen, I think is still the thinnest.I remember seeing newOrder in NYC on 7/7/83 at the Paradise Garage and remembering how skinny he was Oh well, oh well.
ps. I am still pissed that they blew off the northeast United States on their tour. Those Europeans cannot possible make them as much money as us Americans can
"i've been good and i've been bad, but common sense I've never had"
Originally posted by Al Jarvis > Originally posted by Ricardo Fernandes> Fish & Chips. Englishmen always eat fish & chips. :D
Even for breakfast, apparently. As was alleged to us in Germany for the Order last weekend. And we all have lots of tattoos. Although someone reckoned I was actually Scottish (Shug, please note) as I had 'tartan' shorts on and Jocks always wear tartan. Said shorts were actually Aquascutum.
Dem der Germans - Scots always wear Tartan? a quelle heure sil vous plait? Rod Stewart and Bay City Roller fans maybe:D
The only time I bring out the tartan flags (which double up nicely as a kilt ) Is when we play you's at footy, tell you what MacJarvie - it's about time they re-introduced The Scotland versus England games - always something to look forward to, and taking over Trafalgar Square fer the weekend;)
