Skip to content

Bernard sings on Joy Division record

Archived

8 replies · 1,157 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Am I the only one that has noticed Bernard Sumner sings the chorus on "They Walked In Line" on the semi-bootleg Warsaw CD? Is it a combination of Hooky and Bernard? Or just Bernard?

0 likes

I always thought it was a combination of both Hooky & Barney. Dunno if it's documented anywhere though mate :thumb:

0 likes

they sang there lines ,they sang there lines , they sang there lines.

all dressed in uniform.

0 likes

I always heard it was Ian w/ Hooky's background vox. Keep in mind, Bernard was the LAST choice/option for singer of New Order. His guitar playing in JD = epic own (See, i.e., The Sound of Music).

0 likes

As good as Hooky's bass on Atrocity Exhibition! Or the powerful drumming on "Gutz" by S. Morris!

0 likes

indiearchivist wrote: As good as Hooky's bass on Atrocity Exhibition! Or the powerful drumming on "Gutz" by S. Morris!

ISN'T it Barney's Bass on Atrocity Exhibition?

0 likes

That was the point! Sorry for the in-joke.

0 likes

Duh!!! i should of got that. oh yeah, hooky played guitar on sound of music also.

0 likes

I thought Steve sang they Walked in Line as well. I wonder if he could sing and drum at the same time. Steve was the first choice to be the lead singer of NO, anyway... Or did I get that wrong?

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗