Tracks:
Love Vigilantes (TV Pitch)
We heard this a few weeks back. Love it. Really cool. Like the extra little bits and to be able to hear the bits normally hidden in the mix under the vocals.
The Perfect Kiss (Writing Session)
Again, something we heard a bit back. Interesting to hear something in such a rudimentary form.
Untitled 1
I agree with comments that it sounds like BLT. The opening and the later bass guitar bits especially. A fun piece. I just wish we had more of it.
Sunrise (Instrumental Rough Mix)
Elegia (Full Length)
It's interesting that GotBlueEyes mentions that these are different mixes than the ones we're used to. I will have to make some comparisons.
Elegia does sound different to my ears, but it's been a while since I listened to the long version.
It does sound bloody incredible. What a great piece of music. Morricone would be envious, I'd guess.
Sooner Than You Think (Full Version)
Nothing too remarkable and I can kind of see why they edited it. Still, pretty nice to have.
Sub-Culture (Instrumental)
Interesting and cool. Funky. Needs some Hooky bass though. Possibly he hadn't written his part at the point this was recorded, maybe? Strange ending. Sounds like they just stopped the sequencer randomly.
Face Up (Writing Session)
You can definitely hear why 'Japanese One' was a working title for this. Nice to hear them letting the sequencer run without anything over the top.
Hook's bass sounds great.
Let's Go
Now you're bloody talking. This is fan-fucking-tastic!
That extra bit of Spanish sounding guitar is just great. So nice to hear a 'release quality' version of this version of the track ('Waiting For So Long', rather than 'Nothing For Me').
The only downside - It just makes me long for a version with vocals (besides the bootleg one we have).
Untitled 2
Yep. This is that track from the 1984 Rehearsals Tape!
Great! Finally, we have an official release.
Hooky's bass is sublime, even in this unfinished version. He sounds like he's having so much fun!
Sunrise (Writing Session)
This is interesting. Always a favourite of mine and always something to really show off Hooky's talent.
Some really nice 'new' bits of guitar and bass.
It's funny to hear it played a bit slower than normal.
Love Vigilantes (Writing)
Nice and cheery version of this classic. Breezes along.
Sharp ending, which sounds a biot strange.
Sooner Than You Think (Writing Session)
Wow! This sounds really 'lounge lizard' style. Very chilled.
I like it.
Skullcrusher (Demo)
Something we heard a week or so ago. It's fine for what it is. I just think it goes on a bit and can see why the Salvation version was a shorter version.
Like the messy guitar end. Makes for a good end of CD2 and reminiscent of the end of 'Face Up' with the record skipping.
You know, looking back on previous box set releases, I wasn't that bowled over by most of the stuff on the PC&L CD2. I found a lot of the 'writing session' stuff was a bit dull (for want of a better word). They mostly all sounded like rough mixes with no vocals. Very little significant differences from the LP versions. There were obviously some exceptions to this, of course (for instance, the excellent and thoroughly interesting early Thieves and Blue Monday versions), but I found most tracks to be 'listen to once or twice and forget about them'. Compared to those Cargo/Western Works demos on the first set, they just paled in comparison (IMHO).
So, coming into this disc, seeing all those 'writing session' tracks, I was a little worried we might get more of the same.
However, I think we got some pretty damn fantastic tracks on this release and I will definitely be listening to them multiple times.
Of course, it would've been nice to have a few more 'songs' than we got, but I'm not complaining. There's lots to love here.
Onto the DVDs...