Skip to content

Retro Disc Poll

Archived

10 replies · 320 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Favourite Retro Disc

Closed
  • Pop 0 (0%)
  • Fan 4 (15%)
  • Club 1 (4%)
  • Live 9 (35%)
  • *Bonus* 12 (46%)

26 votes · voting closed

Had a quick look and cant believe this poll hasnt been done before!! (tho apologies if it has and i've missed it!)

My view for one has changed from what i thought would be my favourite disc to what actually is my favourite disc since i got the boxset.

0 likes

I vote for Fan. This is really a fine selection.

0 likes

i've only played the live, club and some of fan so far but i love this little box thing altogether. what a great thing to own by a great band. all those songs and 5 cd's for 25 quid, its a gem of a set even though its not to everyones taste and could of had more, but ill be sniffing it and stroking it for years to come. i still think they could of put another early concert on the finsbury dvd, especially a technique gig, which i'd really love to have. any floating about??? :)

0 likes

hmmmm...I'm the only one that likes the club disc the best...oh well...I made my employees listen to this over and over Saturday night...I think they are happy that I'm leaving now!!!

0 likes

I've got a multi-CD player (5 CD's, actually), so I always listen to the 5 discs of Retro mixed together in random order. It sounds very good so, though each individual disc is rather disppointing imho.

0 likes

Originally posted by Tout est devenu vert I've got a multi-CD player (5 CD's, actually), so I always listen to the 5 discs of Retro mixed together in random order. It sounds very good so, though each individual disc is rather disppointing imho.

:nod:

same here, although mine makes a right fuss and dance when it switches between discs.

Still its a nice way of listening to the tracks though as your in anticipation of whats coming up next :)

0 likes

I'd vote for the Live disc.

I'd have liked to choose Club, but what with the horribly foreshortened 'Regret' and 'Touched By The Hand Of God', not to mention that 'Shellshock' and 'Bizarre Love Triangle' could have been replaced by their respective dub versions, I'm feeling a little short-changed on that one.

I've not even bothered to play Pop; bit too familiar.

0 likes

Anyone care to explain what EGG is doing on the 'club' disc?? :confused:

0 likes

I really like the Fan disk - I think they did a good job of getting the tracks that the true fans love, leaving out the fluff.

0 likes

The Fan disk is quite good but i voted for the bonus disk because of Temptation98. It sounds soooo gooood :music:

0 likes

Originally posted by Be Music The Fan disk is quite good but i voted for the bonus disk because of Temptation98. It sounds soooo gooood :music:

It's my least favorite version of Temptation.

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗