Someone raised this question in the 'Twisted Tenderness best song' thread. Do not simply pick the song you prefer, but select the one which does the best job as an album ending.
Dates
· UTC
Big ends, small dicks
Archived36 replies · 1,474 views
This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.
Which is the best last song?
Closed-
I remember nothing (Unknown Pleasures) 0 (0%)
-
Decades (Closer) 22 (26%)
-
Denial (Movement) 2 (2%)
-
Leave me alone (Power, Corruption & Lies) 20 (24%)
-
Face up (Low Life) 6 (7%)
-
Every little counts (Brotherhood) 6 (7%)
-
Dream attack (Technique) 24 (29%)
-
Avalanche (Republic) 1 (1%)
-
Run wild (Get Ready) 3 (4%)
84 votes · voting closed
Every little counts.. how many times did I manage to tell people their CD player was toasted with the ending...
However, it has never been the ending on the CD... 
thats a tough one for me...
its between denial. decades or dream attack...mmmmm
oh look, they all begin with d's.
dream attack just shades it for me i think, very close that one.
Seeing as my copy of PCL ends with "The Beach" instead of Leave Me Alone, I had to go with Face-up. I'm just a sucker for that song....
Originally posted by Taboo # 7 Seeing as my copy of PCL ends with "The Beach" instead of Leave Me Alone, I had to go with Face-up. I'm just a sucker for that song....
Well, yes, Face-up is very good, but how can you pass up the chance to vote for LMA in any category where it's eligible?
LMA should win this easily. The real best end song is the end of side A on Low Life. It technically does not count. But, when you have the tape and Sunrise finishes with the bell chime you realize that you have just witnessed perfection...
LMA itself ends beautifully, melodically; and I think that's what makes it a good album closer. Doesn't it make you think "I've just listened to a great album"? That last chord gives a warm glow every time. In today's terms a "chill-out" after a euphoric experience.
I couldn't vote, I like Dream attack and Leave me alone equally, that is a really hard one to pick
Behind Closed Doors on my Get Ready...(I'm in Japan)
But it is a toss up between Dream Attack and Decades...definately!!!
Oh man, this is a hard one, why didn't somebody tell me there was gonna be a quiz here??!!!
Dream Attack!!!!!!
LMA and Dream Attack would both go very close if it were just a New Order poll, but as JD have been included, it has to be Decades, as the ultimate closer.
Man, this was tough...but I went with Dream Attack. However, Face-up is a brilliant song, and Leave Me Alone (though not the last song on my version of PCL) is a great song, too.
Originally posted by M. Domingo Leave Me Alone (though not the last song on my version of PCL) is a great song, too.
The pitty with international releases is that they often include bonus tracks which do not really fit in the album. An album is not only the random juxtaposition of 8 or 10 songs. It has got a spirit of its own and, specially with New Order, it leaves a long lasting aftertaste which is completely spoiled by the extra tracks. I hate having SOTN on Brotherhood, and I would hate to have Blue Monday or The Beach on PCL, TPK full length at the end of Low-life, Don't Do It or Best & Marsh at the end of Technique...
And still no one knows the record that was scratched at the end of 'every little counts' :\ohwell:
Good question...hard to say! I remember a snippet from "Pleasures & Wayward Distractions" about a comparison between ELC and Lou Reed's "Walk On The Wild Side", though they never did mention where that scratched record was sampled from...
Originally posted by M. Domingo Good question...hard to say! I remember a snippet from "Pleasures & Wayward Distractions" about a comparison between ELC and Lou Reed's "Walk On The Wild Side", though they never did mention where that scratched record was sampled from...
One of the US 87 gigs - Pittsburgh - they start playing "Walk on the Wild Side" in the middle of "Every Little Counts", with Barney actually knowing the lyrics !
Originally posted by M. Domingo Dear Gods, Benny...exactly how many times have you seen NO? :p
Only 52, but I have ten times that in live recordings !
Denial does the best job of wrapping up an LP for me. Opinion of whether or not one likes the song or the LP it closes does not matter here, it's the sheer agression in the song after what's just gone before in the previous 7 tracks that really clinches it.
I would have voted Decades but I always have viewed it as going hand in hand with The Eternal - the 2 songs are inseperable as far as I'm concerned.
My vote went to Dream Attack - as good as many of the alternatives are, this is one of my all time faves.
An honourable mention must go to Avalanche though. After the troubled birth of Republic & the post Reading split, to keep hearing them ending by singing 'Faith' always kinda gave me hope that all was not lost. Roll forward 5 years to Apollo98 & the faith was amply rewarded. :) :) :) :) :)
Originally posted by Jordan L My vote went to Dream Attack - as good as many of the alternatives are, this is one of my all time faves.An honourable mention must go to Avalanche though. After the troubled birth of Republic & the post Reading split, to keep hearing them ending by singing 'Faith' always kinda gave me hope that all was not lost. Roll forward 5 years to Apollo98 & the faith was amply rewarded.:) :) :) :) :)
And that small 5 letter word was the last we heard of Gillian... 
Myself, I'm a big fan of Denial, and think this is a very underrated song. But there's little that doesn't pale in comparison with Decades. Anywhere. From anyone.
Wow!!! I seriously thought that "decades" would run away with it. Decades is the one for sure. One of the most haunting and beautiful pieces of music ever commited to vinyl. As the closing track to the album, it's stunning. Ian curtis sounds like a ghost.
