A great song, recorded between "Movement" and "PC&L" and along with "Procession", "EEG", "Mesh", "Temptation" and "Hurt" these six songs show how quickly they were changing and progressing. "C & W" is my favourite song by newOrder. So what do you think of it?
Dates
· UTC
CRIES AND WHISPERS
Archived38 replies · 8,835 views
This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.
it precedes movement, along with procession and mesh. these were all features of their earliest gigs and are the very first new order material, both mesh and cries and whispers also had completely different lyrics in all those early live appearances
It's a curious one. Started life right at the beginning of New Order, and got dropped from the live set as soon as they'd written most of Movement. Then for some reason got dragged out again to be recorded (was it a Movement outtake I wonder ?), but didn't return to the live set until the 83 US tour, when it was a pretty regular feature. On their return to England it was dropped forever. Mesh was always lumped in together, and had a similar fate expect it didn't reappear on the US 83 tour.
... and I will remind eveyone who doesn't already know that it IS the one on the Substance CD! (mislabeled Mesh - funny noises at start like a demented police car!)
Originally posted by E.Costello It's a curious one. Started life right at the beginning of New Order, and got dropped from the live set as soon as they'd written most of Movement. Then for some reason got dragged out again to be recorded (was it a Movement outtake I wonder ?), but didn't return to the live set until the 83 US tour, when it was a pretty regular feature. On their return to England it was dropped forever. Mesh was always lumped in together, and had a similar fate expect it didn't reappear on the US 83 tour.
I wonder were you can find a live version of this? i would love to hear it.
Originally posted by Slippy ... and I will remind eveyone who doesn't already know that it IS the one on the Substance CD! (mislabeled Mesh - funny noises at start like a demented police car!)
It took me ages to figure that out.
could someone send me a version of Cries and Wisphers and Mesh? i dont know the differance.....in fact can anyone let me hear all 6 of the inbetween songs lol
Cries & Whispers= Begins with droning synth "Bellow the surface..."
Mesh = Hooky's bass starts it, "Full of desire..etc."
Originally posted by Spike okie so substance put the wrong name i think i got it know, but never heard MEsh then....
Spike, can you check the VIETNAM thread, it's above this one. 
Originally posted by Buffer Low
> Originally posted by Spike> okie so substance put the wrong name i think i got it know, but never heard MEsh then....
Spike, can you check the VIETNAM thread, it's above this one.
At least it was.
Originally posted by CuanaD Never realy liked C&W much (or Country & Western), but I like Mesh a lot more!
I think you are the first person to say that, well done mate.
Best bit 2. Worst bit 3. Why love/hate? 4. Rating (%)
Nice synths, and when Steve's drumming goes ballistic towards the middle/end, what kind of drum mod/kit was he using? Hooky's bass also really comes out here (where it bloody well should be).
Barney's voice isn't quite there yet, but the lyrics and his delivery make up for it.
Should've been on Movement instead of "The Him" or "ICB"
79%
Originally posted by Buffer Low
I think you are the first person to say that, well done mate.
WoHoo, I'm famous!:D
Originally posted by CuanaD > Originally posted by Buffer Low
I think you are the first person to say that, well done mate.
WoHoo, I'm famous!:D Um...No...Not really mate.
Originally posted by aaron dawson i like the synths. the ending is great.
I like the synths too, but for me, the beginning is great. 
Check the Song Browser for live dates. There were a few 1980 gigs on STG that had these tunes. Loved Hooky singing Mesh, sounded very new wave.
One of my favs... best bit for me is where Hooky is picking harmonics on his 6 string bass during the 'ship sails out to sea' verse. Great live track.
It's possibly my all-time favorite New Order song. It's definately in my top 5. The lyrics are some of Barney's best.
The beginning synths are great - quite ominous.
But the best part is the 7 seconds from 1:57 - 2:03. I could listen to this part of the song all day.
The only part I don't like is that in parts of the song some of the effects drown out the bass - or maybe that's only my hearing going in old age. :D
I love this period of stuff around the Movement time - you can smell the evolution... makes you wonder if they'd gone this way with Ian still around...
Buffer Low wrote:
Originally posted by CuanaD Never realy liked C&W much (or Country & Western), but I like Mesh a lot more!
I think you are the first person to say that, well done mate.
count me in there too, i like mesh better than cries and whispers
