Skip to content

Bands that lost their cred

Archived

50 replies · 1,336 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Listening to the first Journey album now (in a cafe). The first album had enormous cred-- the band was a Santana offshoot, after all-- then the band abandoned their claim to serious musicianship to pursue pop stardom.

:wtf:

Must be other bands out there that started out with such promise only to throw it all away for commercial success...

0 likes

Shamen (pre-C awesome, Post-C, utter wank, even Colin's gated Westone guitar could not keep me listening)

Happy Mondays (Step on made me Step OFF, although Kinky Afro was one more highlight after that)

Goldfrapp (cos the last album of theirs I heard had 8 versions of the same 6/8 time glam rock riff and fuck all else on it)

0 likes

Doctor? wrote: Shamen (pre-C awesome, Post-C, utter wank, even Colin's gated Westone guitar could not keep me listening)

Happy Mondays (Step on made me Step OFF, although Kinky Afro was one more highlight after that)

Goldfrapp (cos the last album of theirs I heard had 8 versions of the same 6/8 time glam rock riff and fuck all else on it)

Steve, the point is that you have to imagine Alison Goldfrapp grinding her crotch into your face in time with said 6/8 glam rock riff.

Then you'll understand the point of the latest Goldfrapp long player.

:nod:

0 likes

lol, u could really go on for hours on this one:

The Proclaimers - okay they didnt have any cred, but "Sunsine on Leith" was a widely popular although shite album, but who knows what happened to them?

FATBACK - Bus Stop - once again, dont think they had any cred either, but that one song that everyone danced that stupid dance to in the late 80's was also v.popular, but lol, did they even bother to release an album. Maybe they knew they were shite.

RIGHT SAID FRED - enuff said, born shite, remains shite.

EMINEM - first few albums were listenable, now he goes ahead and releases a mix tape (what the?).

BLOC PARTY - Silent Alarm was absolute brilliance, then they release TWO MORE YEARS (very worthy), then they come out with their new album "A weekend in the city" - which in my mind is absolute crap apart from that one song "The Prayer"....**okay i shouldnt be talking about an unreleased album, but hey we live in the internet age, everythings available ahead of time if you look in the right places**.

Shall io go on, nah :\

0 likes

Doctor Clayhead wrote:

Doctor? wrote: Shamen (pre-C awesome, Post-C, utter wank, even Colin's gated Westone guitar could not keep me listening)

Happy Mondays (Step on made me Step OFF, although Kinky Afro was one more highlight after that)

Goldfrapp (cos the last album of theirs I heard had 8 versions of the same 6/8 time glam rock riff and fuck all else on it)

Steve, the point is that you have to imagine Alison Goldfrapp grinding her crotch into your face in time with said 6/8 glam rock riff.

Then you'll understand the point of the latest Goldfrapp long player.

:nod:

I think the last time I bought a record cos of wanting to do an involved female was when I was about 13....I got some funny attitudes to music thereafter, and one of them is hating anything that is sold on sex. Having said that, it's a good point well made, and Miss G is well doable for an auld doll.

It's just that none of the tunes are a patch on lovely head[1] the first of theirs I ever heard, that vocal filtration thing through the synth just knocked me dead) or utopia or pilots.

0 likes

chumbawumba

0 likes

Red Hot Chili Peppers - Stadium Arcadium is one of the most bloated albums released.

The Exploited - Embracing thrash metal:nonono:

Discharge - See above

Megadeth - Cryptic Writing

Killing Joke - Outside the Gate (shudder) but thankfully they rectified that with Extremities, Dirt and Various Repressed Emotions.

0 likes

Rolling Stones,if they'd split late 70's they'd be as legendary as the Beatles.

U2. The politics ruined the pop.

0 likes

Madonna - after Vouge

Van Halen - after David left (although I do like some Van Hagar tunes)

DM - after Violater

Motley Crue - after they stopped doing drugs

Sisqo - his follow up to Thong Song, Granny Panties, just didn't work out for him.....

0 likes

Tex wrote: Madonna - after Vouge

Motley Crue - after they stopped doing drugs

Sisqo - his follow up to Thong Song, Granny Panties, just didn't work out for him.....

:skeptic: :skeptic:

All of these had cred? :uhoh:

0 likes

Christopher Owens wrote:

Tex wrote: Madonna - after Vouge

Motley Crue - after they stopped doing drugs

Sisqo - his follow up to Thong Song, Granny Panties, just didn't work out for him.....

:skeptic: :skeptic:

All of these had cred? :uhoh:

Madge and MC had certain amounts of cred on this side of the pond. Sisqo was my lame attempt at humor.

*backing away from keyboard muttering, "a thousand pardons..."* :D

0 likes

Adam and the Ants...

0 likes

Tex wrote: Madonna - after Vouge

Van Halen - after David left (although I do like some Van Hagar tunes)

DM - after Violater

Motley Crue - after they stopped doing drugs

Sisqo - his follow up to Thong Song, Granny Panties, just didn't work out for him.....

I agree with you on DM, sadly. The first two post-Wilder albums were very weak, although Playing the Angel was rather good. Although Alan Wilder played on Songs of Faith and Devotion, he seemed absent from the album, kind of like Hooky's absense from Republic. Actually, SOFAD is a lot like Republic, for both albums followed what is considered the band's pinnacle of their work and are both considered artistic let downs. If the album had synths on it, it wouldn't have been bad, but the excessive, boring guitars and religious lyrics (they seem to have forgotten "Blasphemous Rumors") make it very sub-par to Violator. If you watch any live footage from that tour, aside from Dave looking strung out and Martin not setting foot near a keyboard, Alan looks like he wants to run off the stage and get the hell out of there. I don't really blame him, either.

0 likes

The Beatles lost it, then got it again. Quite a feat.

U2 have to be the most severe case of cred loss ever though. What is that all about?

0 likes

Tex wrote:

Madge and MC had certain amounts of cred on this side of the pond. Sisqo was my lame attempt at humor.

*backing away from keyboard muttering, "a thousand pardons..."* :D

I'll let you off with S***o, but Motley Crue???

You have got to be joking.

They were shit.

They are shit.

They will forever remain shit.

Hair *metal*:nonono: :nonono:

0 likes

New Order when they lost their enigmatic keyboard genius, acted like they were bothered and turned up for a series of gigs.

Cheers

0 likes

REM - once they went "public"

U2 - Once Bono thought he was Africa's saviour it turned to crap

0 likes

This blue-eyed boy that wants to be wrote: I agree with you on DM, sadly. The first two post-Wilder albums were very weak, although Playing the Angel was rather good. Although Alan Wilder played on Songs of Faith and Devotion, he seemed absent from the album, kind of like Hooky's absense from Republic [...] Alan looks like he wants to run off the stage and get the hell out of there. I don't really blame him, either.

I totally agree with you. On the other hand, the Recoil albums since he left Depeche Mode are masterpieces.

Vivat Recoil !

0 likes

Jiphy wrote:

This blue-eyed boy that wants to be wrote: I agree with you on DM, sadly. The first two post-Wilder albums were very weak, although Playing the Angel was rather good. Although Alan Wilder played on Songs of Faith and Devotion, he seemed absent from the album, kind of like Hooky's absense from Republic [...] Alan looks like he wants to run off the stage and get the hell out of there. I don't really blame him, either.

I totally agree with you. On the other hand, the Recoil albums since he left Depeche Mode are masterpieces.

Vivat Recoil !

I don't know, the only DM album I don't care for is SOFAD, everything else I really like.:shrug:

0 likes

EdelBrock wrote: I don't know, the only DM album I don't care for is SOFAD, everything else I really like.:shrug:

To me DM albums are :

Music for the Masses Ultra Violator Black Celebration and... Playing the Angels

I have some others... They are more like pieces of my record collection than anything else.

0 likes

Jiphy wrote:

EdelBrock wrote: I don't know, the only DM album I don't care for is SOFAD, everything else I really like.:shrug:

To me DM albums are :

Music for the Masses Ultra Violator Black Celebration and... Playing the Angels

I have some others... They are more like pieces of my record collection than anything else.

Surely you can't hate: Some Great Reward People are People

Some of the early stuff I can understand, but those are top albums:thumb:

0 likes

EdelBrock wrote:

Surely you can't hate: Some Great Reward People are People

Some of the early stuff I can understand, but those are top albums:thumb:

The best tunes out of those are compiled elsewhere... It is enought for me. I tried to listen to these albums and I skipped almost every songs... By the way People are People has not been released in Europe.

0 likes

Jiphy wrote:

EdelBrock wrote:

Surely you can't hate: Some Great Reward People are People

Some of the early stuff I can understand, but those are top albums:thumb:

The best tunes out of those are compiled elsewhere... It is enought for me. I tried to listen to these albums and I skipped almost every songs... By the way People are People has not been released in Europe.

Didn't know that...is there another album with the same songs rearranged? Kinda like a "louder than bombs" thing?

0 likes

EdelBrock wrote: Didn't know that...is there another album with the same songs rearranged? Kinda like a "louder than bombs" thing?

Sorry for my English.

I meant that out of Construction Time Again, Some Great Rewards and Black Celebration I have no interest in the songs which are not singles except Something to do as far as I can remember.

In fact 50% of Black Celebration do not interest me at all (including some singles). Well, I do not like songs like a question of lust, somebody...

I remember that I had People Are People as an American collection of tracks but I cannot tell you who stole me that one. And I do not think these songs were rearranged. By the time, anyway.

I also do not care about remasterisations they release nowadays either... It inteferes with my memories... As Dave Gahan says "it's no good". These songs belong to their time... I do not want to listen to them after a plastic surgery operation today... It sounds too fake to my ears...

0 likes

Dépêche Mode.

There was a play on words with their name. Swap a few letters and it becomes Dépède Moche. If you say that, a French speaking man will understand Des Pèdes Moches which can be translate by : Ugly Gays...

Stupid play on words by the ones who disliked the girlish aspect of that band back in the eighties...

0 likes

EdelBrock wrote:

Jiphy wrote:

EdelBrock wrote:

Surely you can't hate: Some Great Reward People are People

Some of the early stuff I can understand, but those are top albums:thumb:

The best tunes out of those are compiled elsewhere... It is enought for me. I tried to listen to these albums and I skipped almost every songs... By the way People are People has not been released in Europe.

Didn't know that...is there another album with the same songs rearranged? Kinda like a "louder than bombs" thing?

Not exactly. People are People and Catching up with Depeche Mode were released in the US to make DM as more popular than a club band. I believe People are People was their first real hit in the US. Their first three albums, I believe, weren't widely available in the US, and People are People shares several of the same songs as Construction Time Again: Love in itself, Told you so, Everything counts, and Pipeline. But it also has some b-sides on it and A Broken Frame song and Get the Balance right. Catching up with DM, which followed the next year, is more of a chronological singles compilation for the US.

0 likes

Stone Roses,about 5 minutes after The Second Coming.

0 likes

Metallica -->> They sound like they are against the man and rooting for the little guy in all the first albums. As soon as Lars can't afford more than 4 exotic cars per year he jumps on the RIAA sue your customers bandwagon. Fudge off Lars and give me an mp3 and the attitude you had during master of puppets. It is obviously not about the music or the fans any more.

Cure -->> c the turtle of enormous girth, no more pornography, faith, or kiss me from this band.

Moz -->> He will always need Johnny and yes I am bitter.

0 likes

rev-2-9k wrote: Moz -->> He will always need Johnny ...

Surely Moz has shown it's the other way around?

0 likes

Comrade Shampanyov wrote:

rev-2-9k wrote: Moz -->> He will always need Johnny ...

Surely Moz has shown it's the other way around?

moz has had great commercial success, he no doubt has as many fans as ever. it is only my humble opinion that the smiths made better music. he also canceled the last concert i had tickets to.

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗