cranelane wrote:
Genetic wrote:
Johnny Giles wrote:
Given Hook's had his lawyers on speed dial over the last 5 years and used that approach to grab the Hac brand for himself (and crucified it), he has set the tone and has noone to blame but himself for the way he's been treated. Hoisted by his own petard I'm afraid.
I dont agree, and thats someone who's been accused of being Pro-Hooky and Anti-Hooky on the same thread on the same day.
Fans like us don't have to be pro or anti any member of the band, it is possible to be pleased that New Order are back but to regret that Hooky isn't involved and also some people here don't like to see Hooky being demonised or seen as some sort of villian when clearly New Order meant as much to him as it did to the others. His ill-tempered comments re the reunion of course played right in the hands of his detractors but maybe folks should give the Hooky bashing a little break now,it's getting tiresome.
Cranelane, I agree in principle that the personal attacks on Hooky have gotten tiresome, but with all the "NO Hooky, No New Order" comments on facebook, I wanted to offer the following perspective.
In my 7 years visiting this forum I hadn't seen any all-out Hooky bashing until the last year or so. And even now I think most of it has been pretty restrained. In contrast, the Bernard bashing has been a regular hobby round here. "Oh, Bernard's songwriting has been wank for ages", "Bernard ruined Republic", "Raise The Pressure is a pile of shite", "His voice has gotten lame since he learned how to sing properly", "Bernard sucks for thinking Movement sucks", "Never Cry Another Tear proves Bernard has lost his way completely", "Bernard NEEDS Hooky", "Bernard has too much of an ego", etc. etc.
Granted those aren't ver batim quotes, but they're pretty close to capturing the drivel Hooky partisans have posted for ages. For chrissakes, it's a fucking bass guitar with a chorus pedal. It's not the heart and soul of NO, just like Ian wasn't the genius behind Steve's hypnotic rhythms or Bernard's guitar riffs. New Order has been a group effort with a de facto band leader, who, frankly, did a bang up job composing (and singing) some great songs. Their golden years may be behind them, but I think Bernard, Steve, and Gillian can make a handful of good tracks sans Hooky. And still be New Order.