okay, so i was thinking about the vocal track on this song. i can't figure out if i like them for being true to the moment they were recorded, or if another take (with out the giggles) would've done the song more justice.
from a musical standpoint, this song has the potential to be one of the greatest ballads NO has done. GG's strings after the pause, through to the end, are beautiful. the record-scratch at the end is a good way to mark the end of the album. but on the other end, we have barney's laughing and some plinking-banjo stuff that contradicts the mood.
is this some work of genius, or just some apathetic kids fucking around with thier own song?