Skip to content

Bells on Who's Joe

Archived

381 replies · 4,185 views

This is an archived legacy thread. Replies are closed, but the discussion is preserved.

Do you hear bells from 0:15 to 0:45 on Who's Joe?

Closed
  • Yes, I hear bells on Who's Joe from 0:15 to 0:45. 19 (50%)
  • No, I don't hear bells on Who's Joe from 0:15 to 0:45. 19 (50%)

38 votes · voting closed

BIGINOIL wrote:

Patrick wrote:

NObabe wrote: From bells to heroes and I'd like to mention Hannibal Lecter, never seen someone so intelligent before. Pardon me for being totally off topic in here.

So far I haven't detected clear references to cannibalism on WFTSC, M, but who knows, anything is possible.:)

There's a monster at the end of the first track. Could he be a flesh-eater?

I would certainly hope so, Big. But that wouldn't be cannibalism, would it?

0 likes

Patrick wrote:

BIGINOIL wrote:

Patrick wrote:

NObabe wrote: From bells to heroes and I'd like to mention Hannibal Lecter, never seen someone so intelligent before. Pardon me for being totally off topic in here.

So far I haven't detected clear references to cannibalism on WFTSC, M, but who knows, anything is possible.:)

There's a monster at the end of the first track. Could he be a flesh-eater?

I would certainly hope so, Big. But that wouldn't be cannibalism, would it?

I realised that as I posted it, but I thought a certain artistic license would be permitted in order that my post would scan a little better.

I realise that I was in error, and will endeavour to ensure that accuracy prevails in future posts.

0 likes

Patrick wrote:

NObabe wrote: From bells to heroes and I'd like to mention Hannibal Lecter, never seen someone so intelligent before. Pardon me for being totally off topic in here.

So far I haven't detected clear references to cannibalism on WFTSC, M, but who knows, anything is possible.:)

There's a monster sound at the end of track two - perhaps that is intended to depict a predatorial human, intent on eating the flesh of an unwilling (human) victim. I wonder if they used a real predatorial human, intent on eating the flesh of an unwilling (human) victim, or synthesised one on a Moog?

0 likes

I hope you don't think I was being overly nitpicky, Big. I wouldn't want you to rethink your participation in this little project. I have the sense that you and I are the only ones who are taking this with the seriousness it deserves.

0 likes

Patrick wrote: I hope you don't think I was being overly nitpicky, Big. I wouldn't want you to rethink your participation in this little project. I have the sense that you and I are the only ones who are taking this with the seriousness it deserves.

I am grateful for the reminder. Thank you sir.

0 likes

BIGINOIL wrote:

Patrick wrote:

NObabe wrote: From bells to heroes and I'd like to mention Hannibal Lecter, never seen someone so intelligent before. Pardon me for being totally off topic in here.

So far I haven't detected clear references to cannibalism on WFTSC, M, but who knows, anything is possible.:)

There's a monster sound at the end of track two - perhaps that is intended to depict a predatorial human, intent on eating the flesh of an unwilling (human) victim. I wonder if they used a real predatorial human, intent on eating the flesh of an unwilling (human) victim, or synthesised one on a Moog?

I don't recall having focused on a monster on track 2; but the more monsters the better, certainly. I think it's probably more of an aesthetic achievement if they faked it.

0 likes

Patrick wrote:

BIGINOIL wrote:

Patrick wrote:

NObabe wrote: From bells to heroes and I'd like to mention Hannibal Lecter, never seen someone so intelligent before. Pardon me for being totally off topic in here.

So far I haven't detected clear references to cannibalism on WFTSC, M, but who knows, anything is possible.:)

There's a monster sound at the end of track two - perhaps that is intended to depict a predatorial human, intent on eating the flesh of an unwilling (human) victim. I wonder if they used a real predatorial human, intent on eating the flesh of an unwilling (human) victim, or synthesised one on a Moog?

I don't recall having focused on a monster on track 2; but the more monsters the better, certainly. I think it's probably more of an aesthetic achievement if they faked it.

Bugger! Another silly posting error!

First track, I meant to say.

Concentrate man - this is important, dammit!

0 likes

Certainly there are no monsters on track 2.

0 likes

I am definitely looking forward to reading that synopsis of The Odyssey that you found, Big.

0 likes

BIGINOIL wrote: There's a monster sound at the end of track two - perhaps that is intended to depict a predatorial human, intent on eating the flesh of an unwilling (human) victim. I wonder if they used a real predatorial human, intent on eating the flesh of an unwilling (human) victim, or synthesised one on a Moog?

That's actually just the sound of Bernard and Hooky devouring a roasted pig.

Have you seen their latest promo shots? Damn!

0 likes

charles wrote: I tried to imitate the "Who's Joe?" intro melody with my synthesizer. http://www.onetransmission.com/mp3/who's%20joe%20intro.mp3

*Great job, Charles. But I don't think this is the sound Patrick is describing as "funeral bells"... is it, Patrick?! It can't be... I don't know, funeral bells in Italy are VERY different. If this is funeral bells, then you can hear them in Krafty and World In Motion as well... ;)

0 likes

Mick Aneworderfan wrote:

charles wrote: I tried to imitate the "Who's Joe?" intro melody with my synthesizer. http://www.onetransmission.com/mp3/who's%20joe%20intro.mp3

*Great job, Charles. But I don't think this is the sound Patrick is describing as "funeral bells"... is it, Patrick?! It can't be... I don't know, funeral bells in Italy are VERY different. If this is funeral bells, then you can hear them in Krafty and World In Motion as well... ;)

An amazing development!

0 likes

Gnu Odor wrote: Bell-like sound, yes, but what I think you're hearing is... artificial harmonics.

*I totally agree. I really thought the supporters of the funeral bells theory reffered to one of the two sounds in the background, the huge metal sound and the remixed Japanese bells, but not these harmonics... I mean, do the funeral bells sound like harmonics in England, so thin and fast? Anyway I think if New Order read this thread, they'd piss themselves laughing at us... ;)

0 likes

I think I'd rather go with that sheep bells theory.

0 likes

I was unsuccessful in attempting to listen to this, unfortunately.

0 likes

Mick Aneworderfan wrote:

Gnu Odor wrote: Bell-like sound, yes, but what I think you're hearing is... artificial harmonics.

*I totally agree. I really thought the supporters of the funeral bells theory reffered to one of the two sounds in the background, the huge metal sound and the remixed Japanese bells, but not these harmonics... I mean, do the funeral bells sound like harmonics in England, so thin and fast? Anyway I think if New Order read this thread, they'd piss themselves laughing at us... ;)

It's not any background sound, it's the sound of the main melody in that time period.

0 likes

Supposing you're from the States, P, when do you sleep?

0 likes

NObabe wrote: Supposing you're from the States, P, when do you sleep?

There are at least six of them, I think.

0 likes

NObabe wrote: Supposing you're from the States, P, when do you sleep?

I'm hoping to go to bed in a couple hours, M, after I read the Odyssey synopsis while listening to WFTSC.

0 likes

BIGINOIL wrote:

NObabe wrote: Supposing you're from the States, P, when do you sleep?

There are at least six of them, I think.

Recall that the view has been expressed that H, DC, and I are really all the same person.

0 likes

Patrick wrote:

NObabe wrote: Supposing you're from the States, P, when do you sleep?

I'm hoping to go to bed in a couple hours, M, after I read the Odyssey synopsis while listening to WFTSC.

You'll be the class swot tomorrow. I've had real people in the house tonight and I have not done any revision at all.

I'll take the cd to work tomorrow, and do some serious cramming tomorrow, when I am on my own.

Are you an American gentleman, Patrick?

0 likes

BIGINOIL wrote:

Patrick wrote:

NObabe wrote: Supposing you're from the States, P, when do you sleep?

I'm hoping to go to bed in a couple hours, M, after I read the Odyssey synopsis while listening to WFTSC.

You'll be the class swot tomorrow. I've had real people in the house tonight and I have not done any revision at all.

I'll take the cd to work tomorrow, and do some serious cramming tomorrow, when I am on my own.

Are you an American gentleman, Patrick?

I'm an American something, Big, I'm not quite sure what.

Well then if I fall asleep while reading the synopsis I won't feel so guilty.

0 likes

Patrick wrote:

I'm an American something, Big, I'm not quite sure what.

Well I am surprised. I would never have guessed. Well done, sir!

0 likes

Got the official release with me today. Still listening on crappy headphones, but I can make out far more detail.

From the top

No Click Some violins Bassy, rolling drums (surely representing thunder) The bells

There's a strange sound underneath the bells - it sounds like an electronic birdsong. It could just be these headphones failing to cope with the bass in the drum, but could also be electronically replicated birdsong.

In keeping with the nautical theme of the album, I am drawn to theorise that this is symbolic of the call of the albatross.

Let's be careful with this. We don't want Coleridge to muscle in on all the good work that has been done with the Greeks. It's a beautiful piece though, a quick read wouldn't do any of us any harm.

The Rime of the Ancient Mariner

0 likes

Interesting find, Biggy. It will take me half an hour to read it.

0 likes

BIGINOIL wrote:

Patrick wrote:

I'm an American something, Big, I'm not quite sure what.

Well I am surprised. I would never have guessed. Well done, sir!

Good morning, Big! And everyone else as well, of course.

If your comment suggests that I might perhaps have done some tiny something to repair my country's damaged international reputation, that would be a good thing.

I did in fact read the synopsis last night, and I have some thoughts to share. It will take a little time to put them in words, so bear with me.

0 likes

Slept in have we Pastie? ... you've missed a minor conflab on mermaids.

Come on, dive in.

:hat:

0 likes

Patrick wrote:

If your comment suggests that I might perhaps have done some tiny something to repair my country's damaged international reputation, that would be a good thing.

I did in fact read the synopsis last night, and I have some thoughts to share. It will take a little time to put them in words, so bear with me.

Good morning, Sir.

I'm so pleased that you received my comments in the spirit they were intended, ie as a complement to your good self rather than a slur on your countrymen.

As you know, I did not do any homework last night as I had humans in the house. They will not be there tonight, so I will devote myself to this important work.

0 likes

BIGINOIL wrote:

Patrick wrote:

If your comment suggests that I might perhaps have done some tiny something to repair my country's damaged international reputation, that would be a good thing.

I did in fact read the synopsis last night, and I have some thoughts to share. It will take a little time to put them in words, so bear with me.

Good morning, Sir.

I'm so pleased that you received my comments in the spirit they were intended, ie as a complement to your good self rather than a slur on your countrymen.

As you know, I did not do any homework last night as I had humans in the house. They will not be there tonight, so I will devote myself to this important work.

I hope you won't be offended, Big, if I say that I feel I know you well enough, even after this short acquaintance, to have been able to understand how your comment was meant.

I was thinking, assuming I can put my thoughts in order, that I might do it on another thread, a new one. Do you think that would be appropriate?

As I've said before, I'm very much looking forward to a productive collaboration on these efforts.

0 likes

Huntsman wrote: Slept in have we Pastie? ... you've missed a minor conflab on mermaids.

Come on, dive in.

:hat:

Good morning, H. I saw it. Yes, I overslept. Sorry. How's the water?

0 likes

You're leaving NewOrderOnline

This link goes to an external website we don't operate, which has its own privacy policy and terms.

Destination:
Continue ↗