TEMPTATION

Ij think the whole song is terrible. It's lijke a joke song to me. Ij can only listen to it after Ij have been heavily drinking.... it sort of numbs my appreciation of the bad points about the song. Pardon me.

The B-side is even worse. Just what were they thinking?

Percentage? You want a percentage? It has to be 90% minus. !!!

Sløvdijk nürlojvka dé !!

1. this song is one of the best things they ever did. Cant sit still when listening to it. I like the lyrics. Actually I like all versions from this song. It is a perfect combination of guitar en dance music. And a year later they made PCL. Wow those were the days :)!
2. worst bit may be the noisy guitar part in the beginning and in the and of the song.
3. see 1
4. 200%
5. at the moment vodka-tonic.

Originally posted by Hånrijk B. & The Hubble Ensémble Ij think the whole song is terrible. It's lijke a joke song to me. Ij can only listen to it after Ij have been heavily drinking.... it sort of numbs my appreciation of the bad points about the song. Pardon me.The B-side is even worse. Just what were they thinking?Percentage? You want a percentage?It has to be 90% minus. !!!Sløvdijk nürlojvka dé !!

You must be joking rijght? Or are you talking about Rock the shack? In that case Ij have to agree (burp)

1. Nothing stands out as it only has bits that are all equally good. 2.___________________________________
2. Probably the impact it has live. It's probably the one that eeks the most sweat out of me.
3. 100%
4. Fresh orange juice, vodka and champagne.

i think we did this one didn't we???

1. Best bit is the lyric, "Thoughts (or bolts, or whatever it is) from above hit the people down below, people in this world we have no place to go". That sends chills down my spine.

2. Worst bit? I don't think there is one. I slightly prefer the Substance version over the original though (sorry!).

3. I love this song from start to finish. New Order's breakthru "guitar song" as opposed to their breakthru "dance song" with Blue Monday. Just a masterpiece.

4. 95%

5. Favorite drink? Alcohol, or otherwise? ;)

I love this song. It is really unique for them. Perhaps their first song that completely sheds the Joy Division legacy--they finally become their own band.

fave drink crown royal on the rocks

Nonsense poetry or sheer brilliance I'll go for the latter

1-4: see other thread 5. white russians

Originally posted by Hanrijk Baldúrsson Ij think the whole song is terrible. It's lijke a joke song to me. Ij can only listen to it after Ij have been heavily drinking.... it sort of numbs my appreciation of the bad points about the song. Pardon me.The B-side is even worse. Just what were they thinking?Percentage? You want a percentage?It has to be 90% minus. !!!Sløvdijk nürlojvka dé !!

WHAT THE HELL? Is this guy completely insane? This song's a classic! Here are my thoughts:

1. Best bit: All of it
2. Worst bit: The fact that it has to end
3. Why I love it: When I was first getting into NO, this was one of the songs that really grabbed my attention; I'd never heard anything like it before. Even now, I still remember that feeling every time I listen to it.
4. Percentage rating: 100%
5. Favourite drink: Alcoholic - Archers Aqua (especially the peach and raspberry flavours); non-alcoholic - Coke

1. Best Bit

The solo on the 12" featuring the sequencer, drum machine and Hooky's base meandering all over the place.

2. Worst Bit

None - all sheer genius

3. Why you love and/or hate it

Love it for Bernard's rather deadpan vocals (cue all early Order) which unfortunately only ever featured again on the next release, Blue Monday. (I liked his 'old' voice). The rather agricultural sequencers combined with powerful drums and the sound effects at the end.

4. Percentile rating

100%

5. What's your favorite drink?

Orkney dark Island Beer, single malt whisky and Rum & Coke (Not combined)

1. The opening sequencer line, and all the variations and changes to it over the years. Oh, and the lyrics - Heaven, a gateway of hope. I could go on.

2. Absoutely nothing. Perfection.

3. I once saw it described in Smash Hits as a song you should give to the most cherished person in your life at least once a year. Says it all. And the memories - it was the theme music to my 1980's.

4. 109%

5. Fullers London Pride.

1. The bouncy sequencer, Stephen's drum work, Barney's crunching guitar intro and lyrics.
2. Only the pre 1985 versions (live) appeal to me for some reason, and the 12" and 7" are passed over for the Substance version and the '98 version...still can't decide which is the best
3. First non "Blue Monday/BLT/True Faith/Regret/Crystal" songs I've heard, and it blew my fuckin' mind watching it on 3 16.
4. 80%
5. Something with caffeine instead of alcohol....hyperactive is the new buzzed

I'll discuss the '82 version only. All the others are inferior for my part. Especially the '87 one. I really hate this one. That said :

1. The last "And i've never met anyone..." part. I really love how Barney sings that.
2. The instrumental part in the midfle might be a little too long...
3. Perfect New Order. That's all.
4. 99%
5. Whisky :D

1. Best Bit: Everything. Femaly voice in backgroud is nice. The bass as usual.
2. Worst Bit: Ehhh... nothing
3. Why you love and/or hate it: A New Order anthem.
4. Percentile rating: 95%
5. What's your favorite drink? Orange juice

Originally posted by Badger! Major did this on Monday...today is Monday...so now I am back on schedule until the Major returns...good enough for all??? I hope so!!!well...looking over the list, I suddenly realized that there is yet another tune that we have yet to cover, and I can't frigging believe that we haven't done this one yet...so for the last one you will see until next Monday (and I swear that I won't spring any surprises again...this is it)....this week (or sort of week)...we are going to look at....TEMPTATION

go for it kids....

1. Best Bit
2. Worst Bit
3. Why you love and/or hate it
4. Percentile rating
5. What's your favorite drink?

Quitelike the vocal ? Hac 90+ When I drank, Absolut limon. Now a St Clemens

I love the original version, the version on "Substance" is a pale imatation of the original. My favourite version is from "Taras Shevchenko", otherwise known as "3 16".

Best bit - the huge, rambling guitar intro on the 12 inch (1981/1982) version & the fact that I can play the keyboard bits Worst bit ? rate: 92% - perty damn good! Drink Brandy & red lemonade - Im 36, at my age you cant drink much guinness anymore

TEMPTATION

1. Best Bit The "nonsense" lyrics, I'm sure in years to come music students will put some sort of meaning to them and debate furiously what he was trying to say. The early live version is classic, souynds liek he was off his tits making them up as he went along.

2. Worst Bit Everything else they've done has to live up to its reputation.

3. Why you love and/or hate it Umm, its a brilliant track. It has the wow factor making you want more.

4. Percentile rating 100%

5. What's your favorite drink? Too many nice ales to mention. Too much single malt as well.

While we are here... I'll tell all these Stella lovers a story. I visit Belgium a lot and its sold in 1 litre plastic bottles to be drunk mostly by Alcoholics. I've only ever seen tourists drink it in the pub. When told how its marketed in the UK a belgium national will piss themselves laughing and mutter "but its the worst beer in belgium"

Enjoy.

1. Best Bit

2. Worst Bit

3. Why you love and/or hate it

4. Percentile rating

5. What's your favorite drink?

6. Umm, all of it.

7. You're not serious, are you?

8. All the things it reminds me of...

9. 100

10. Bacardi and Tizer. Ha, right!

Hmmm, as long as this topic is back at the forefront, I have a Temptation question. This has been bugging me for about a month now. Right around Thanksgiving, I was at the Gap here in L.A.. I was just about to leave the store when I heard the music for Temptation come on. I could immediately tell it was a cover, but when the vocals kicked in, they were completely new lyrics. Basically it was a girl on vocals with guy coming in every now and then to rap during the barney riff. I asked one of the employees if they knew who sang it but of course she didn't know.

Fast forward to yesterday and I hear it again at another Gap. It must be on a Gap Holiday Mix cd of theirs or something, I don't know. The song really isn't that great, I'm just really curious about what group is doing it.

Anyone have any idea??

I love the song. Or I used to love it... I'm a bit bored of it. I don't know why - maybe because they perform it at EVERY gig. And as a matter of fact it became so perfect and polished - a real masterpiece of course - but that's what eventually got me tired of that.

My favourite version is the 1993 Montereiuxx one. I was never really fond of the Substance version (too loud and messy) and I heard the original 12" & 7" vesrions only a few years ago. Man, they sound so gloomy! But they have a charm. ;)

But I've always appreciated the original b-side (as it was on Substance), "Hurt". What the hell were they doing in the studio?? Sounds fantastic and extraordinary.